“Rakovsky Incident”: the Strategy of the Conduct by Soviet Plenipotentiary in Paris

Keywords: Ch. Rakovsky, plenipotentiary, Franco-Soviet relations, Paris, Moscow

Abstract

The article investigates the activities of the Soviet plenipotentiary in Paris in the period of August-October 1927 in connection with the «Rakovsky Incident» - a scandal in the French press that arose after the signing of Ch. Rakovsky in early August 1927 of a statement by the left opposition. Four main areas of activity were identified: contacts with French politicians; cooperation with french press; a new proposal on the Franco-Soviet agreement on debts and credits; interaction with Moscow. The Soviet plenipotentiary in Paris, trying to use all his contacts and acquaintances, tried to get in touch with various French politicians and enlist their support. But the growing campaign of criticism regarding the “Rakovsky case” led to the fact that fewer and fewer politicians contacted him, or only gave empty assurances of support. Even Ch. Rakovsky’s close friend, Anatole de Monzie, behaved extremely indecisively. On the other hand, as recorded in a number of documents, Ch. Rakovsky himself sometimes behaved too self-confidently, ignoring advices. Regarding the press, with the exacerbation of the campaign, the number of newspapers that were ready to cooperate with the Soviet plenipotentiary in Paris decreased. Some of them paid money for it, some printed critical material at the direction of the owners of these newspapers, some followed the dominant trend of criticism of a diplomat. Only the newspaper of the Communist Party - "L'Humanité" - until the end remained loyal to the Soviet plenipotentiary. Ch. Rakovsky laid great hopes on his new proposal for debts and credits. But it was criticized by literally everyone: French politicians, the Paris press, and even their own Soviet government (in close cooperation with which these theses were developed). The leadership of the USSR in the person of I. Stalin spent a lot of effort to discredit Ch. Rakovsky and worsen his situation. This was especially vivid during the period of «Incident». By September 13, official Moscow was silent, and all requests for assistance and proposals for improving the situation were essentially ignored. All of the above was the reason for the very poor efficiency of Ch. Rakovsky’s actions and led to his further departure from France.

Downloads

Download data is not yet available.

References

AVP RF a. Arkhiv vneshney politiki Rosiyskoy Federatsii [Archive of the foreign policy of the Russian Federation], f. 04, op. 42, p. 268, d. 53791. (In Russian)

Архив внешней политики Российской Федерации, ф. 04, оп. 42, п. 268, д. 53791.

AVP RF b. Arkhiv vneshney politiki Rosiyskoy Federatsii [Archive of the foreign policy of the Russian Federation], f. 04, op. 42, p. 269, d. 53824. (In Russian)

Архив внешней политики Российской Федерации, ф. 04, оп. 42, п. 269, д. 53824.

AVP RF c. Arkhiv vneshney politiki Rosiyskoy Federatsii [Archive of the foreign policy of the Russian Federation], f. 04, op. 42, p. 269, d. 53825. (In Russian)

Архив внешней политики Российской Федерации, ф. 04, оп. 42, п. 269, д. 53825.

AVP RF d. Arkhiv vneshney politiki Rosiyskoy Federatsii [Archive of the foreign policy of the Russian Federation], f. 04, op. 42, p. 269, d. 53827. (In Russian)

Архив внешней политики Российской Федерации, ф. 04, оп. 42, п. 269, д. 53827.

AVP RF e. Arkhiv vneshney politiki Rosiyskoy Federatsii [Archive of the foreign policy of the Russian Federation], f. 0136, op. 11, p. 117, d. 306. (In Russian)

Архив внешней политики Российской Федерации, ф. 0136, оп. 11, п. 117, д. 306.

Golovko V. A., Stanchev M. G., Chernyavskiy G. I. 1994: Mezhdu Moskvoy i Zapadom: Diplomaticheskaya deyatelnost Kh. G. Rakovskogo [Between Moscow and the West: the diplomatic activity of Ch. G. Rakovsky]. Kharkiv. (In Russian)

Головко В. А., Станчев М. Г., Чернявский Г. И. 1994: Между Москвой и Западом: дипломатическая деятельность Х. Г. Раковского. Харьков.

Dokumenty vneshney politiki SSSR [Documents of foreign policy of the USSR]. 1965: Moskva. Т. 10. (In Russian)

Документы внешней политики СССР. 1965: Москва. Т. 10.

Ken O. N. 2004: Mobilizatsionnoye planirovaniye v kontekste vnutrenney politiki i mezhdunarodnogo polozheniya SSSR: 1927-1935 gg. Diss. … d-ra ist. nauk. Sankt-Peterburg. (In Russian)

Кен О. Н. 2004: Мобилизационное планирование в контексте внутренней политики и международного положения СССР: 1927-1935 гг. Дисс. … д-ра ист. наук. Санкт-Петербург.

Kommunisticheskaya oppozitsiya v SSSR. Iz arkhiva L'va Trotskogo [Communist opposition in the USSR. From the archive of Leo Trotsky]. 1988: Chalidze publications. T. 4. (In Russian)

Коммунистическая оппозиция в СССР. Из архива Льва Троцкого. 1988: Chalidze publications. Т. 4.

Lobanova M. V. 2006: Rossiyskiy dolg Frantsii i revolyutsionnaya mental'nost' (po materialam sovetskogo diplomata KH. G. Rakovskogo, 1920-ye gody). Problemy ekonomicheskoy istorii: mundus oeconomicus [Problems of economic history: mundus oeconomicus],169-192. (In Russian)

Лобанова М. В. 2006: Российский долг Франции и революционная ментальность (по материалам советского дипломата Х. Г. Раковского, 1920-е годы). Проблемы экономической истории: mundus oeconomicus, 169-192.

Panayotov F. 2003: Zhivotat i smartta na Krastyu Rakovski [The Life and Death of Krastyu Rakovsky]. Sofiya. (In Bulgarian)

Панайотов Ф. 2003: Животът и смъртта на Кръстю Раковски. София.

Pechat' o novykh" predlozheníyakh" Rakovskago. 1927: Posledniye novosti [Last news] 2377, 1. (In Russian)

Печать о новыхъ предложеніяхъ Раковскаго. 1927: Последние новости 2377, 1.

Provokatsionnaya kampaniya. 1927: Izvestiya [News] 209 (3143), 1. (In Russian)

Провокационная кампания. 1927: Известия 209 (3143), 1.

Sirotkin V. 1990: KH. G. Rakovskiy. Samyy yevropeizirovannyy iz bol'shevikov. Diplomaticheskiy yezhegodnik [Diplomatic Yearbook]. Moskva. S. 398-415. (In Russian)

Сироткин В. 1990: Х. Г. Раковский. Самый европеизированный из большевиков. Дипломатический ежегодник. Москва. С. 398-415.

Soglasheniye o dolgakh. 1927: Izvestiya [News] 218 (3152), 1. (In Russian)

Соглашение о долгах. 1927: Известия 218 (3152), С. 1.

Chernyavskiy G. I., Stanchev M. G., Tortika (Lobanova) M. V. 2014: Zhiznennyy put Khristiana Rakovskogo. Yevropeizm i bolshevizm: neokonchennaya duel [The life path of Christian Rakovsky. Europeanism and Bolshevism: unfinished duel]. Moskva. (In Russian)

Чернявский Г. И., Станчев М. Г., Тортика (Лобанова) М. В. 2014: Жизненный путь Христиана Раковского. Европеизм и большевизм: неоконченная дуэль. Москва.

Bernus P. 1927: Les dissensions bolchévistes. Journal des débats politiques et littéraire [Journal of Political and Literary Debates] 229, 1. (In French)

Broué P. 1996: Rakovsky ou la Révolution dans tous les pays [Rakovsky or the Revolution in all countries]. Fayard. (In French)

Bulletin du jour. Le cas de M. Rakowsky. 1927: Le Temps [The Time] 24124, 1. (In French)

Conte F. 1975: Christian Rakovski (1873-1941). Essai de biographie politique [Christian Rakovsky (1873-1941). Political biography essay]. Paris. (In French)

L’incident Rakowsky. 1927: Excelsior [Excelsior], 6111, 3. (In French)

L’ambassadeur désavoué télégraphie de Royat…. 1927: Le Matin [The Morning] 15874, 1. (In French)

M. Rakowski ergote sur son cas. 1927: L'Écho de Paris [The Echo of Paris] 16621, 3. (In French)

Une mise au point de Rakowski. 1927: L'Humanité [Humanity] 10494, 3. (In French)

Une note justificative de M. Rakowsky. 1927: Le Petit Parisien [The Petit Parisien] 18451, 1. (In French)

Published
2019-12-20
How to Cite
Shkabura, Y. I. (2019). “Rakovsky Incident”: the Strategy of the Conduct by Soviet Plenipotentiary in Paris. The Journal of V. N. Karazin Kharkiv National University. Series: History, (56), 125-134. https://doi.org/10.26565/2220-7929-2019-56-12