Female Leadership in the Communities of the Khlysty (Flagellants) and Skoptsi (Eunuchs), 17th to Early 20th Centuries
Abstract
The article sets out to outline the genesis of female leadership in the sects of the Khlysty (Flagellants) and Skoptsi (Eunuchs); find whether its nature changed during the period from the mid-17th to the early 20th centuries; define the types of female leadership in these religious communities; compare its characteristics between the two sects; and trace the mutual influence between the social practices of female leadership and the folklore tradition of the ‘mystical sects.’ The study draws on the principles of gender history. The source base includes both texts produced within the sects and ‘external’ testimony, such as records of state authorities and the official church, works by early Old Believer leaders, and ethnographic observation. The author argues that female leadership among the Khlysty was made possible by their radical rejection of marriage and was closely connected with the gradual strengthening of the role of Virgin Mary in Khlysty folklore. Three types of female leadership among the Khlysty and Skoptsi are distinguished. The first type can be defined through the identification of the leader with the Mother of God, and the second type presupposed community leadership and belief in the special mystical abilities of women, but without conferring on the leader the status of ‘the Mother of God.’ The third type was temporary leadership, in which only at certain moments a woman uttered prophecies that the congregation perceived as the voice of the Holy Spirit. In the period from the mid-17th to early 18th centuries, the institution of Khlysty ‘Mothers of God’ already existed, and in some Khlysty communities women played an important role in cult practices. Most recorded instances of fully independent women leaders among the Khlysty occur in the period from the late 1710s to the middle of the 18th century, primarily because of the spread of Khlysty beliefs in the church milieu, particularly in women’s monasteries. From the mid-18th century on, we can observe a rapid decline of the practice of fullfledged female leadership among the Khlysty and Skoptsi. This is due to the elimination of the most prominent female leader figures, as well as to the fact that at this time monasteries as sectarian centers were almost completely replaced by villages, which were characterized by conservative views and traditional family relations.
Downloads
References
Ajvazov, I. G. Materialy issledovanija russkih misticheskih sekt, vyp. 1, t. I. Moskva, 1916. (In Russian)
Arzumanova, T. V. Relihijne povsiakdennia khlystiv u ХІХ st. (na prykladi Kharkivs'koi hubernii). Novi storinky istorii Donbasu [New Pages of Donbas History], no. 25, 2016, s. 134– 145. (In Ukrainian)
Arzumanova, T. V. Stereotypy schodo shliubu ta intymnoho zhyttia khlystiv u ХІХ — na pochatku ХХ stolittia (na prykladi Kharkivs'koi hubernii). Visnyk Kharkivs'koho natsional'noho universytetu imeni V. N. Karazina. Seriia «Istoriia Ukrainy. Ukrainoznavstvo: istorychni ta filosofs'ki nauky» [V. N. Karazin Kharkiv National University Bulletin ‘History of Ukraine. Ukrainian Studies: Historical and Philosophical Sciences’], vyp. 23, 2017, s. 53–59. (In Ukrainian)
Barsov, N. P. Duhovnye stihi (raspevcy) sekty Ljudej Bozhiih. Sankt-Peterburg, 1870 (In Russian)
Berman, A. G. Gendernye otnoshenija v misticheskih sektah Srednego Povolzh'ja. Livejournal, 11 chervnja 2007, http://andber.livejournal.com/71387.html?thread=330459. Data peregljadu: 1 bereznja 2021. (In Russian)
Berman, A. G. Sekta hlystov v Rossii: rannjaja istorija i religija. Cheboksary, 2020. (In Russian)
Bonch-Bruevich, V. (red.). Materialy k istorii i izucheniju russkogo sektantstva i raskola. Vyp. 1. Baptisty. Beguny. Duhoborcy. L. Tolstoj o skopchestve. Pavlovcy. Pomorcy. Staroobrjadcy. Skopcy. Shtundisty. Sankt-Peterburg, 1908. (In Russian)
Brown, J. Female Sexuality and Madness in Russian Culture: Traditional Values and Psychiatric Theory. Social Research, vol. 53, no. 2, Sexuality and Madness, 1986, pp. 369–385.
Butkevich, T. I. Obzor russkih sekt i ih tolkov. Har'kov, 1910. (In Russian)
Chemers, M. An Integrative Theory of Leadership. New York, 1997.
Chernysh, A. V. Khrystoverye v ystoryy Tsentral'no-Chernozemnoho rehyona Rossyy: XVIII — nachalo XX veka. Vestnyk Cheliabynskoho hosudarstvennoho unyversyteta [Bulletin of Chelyabinsk State University], no. 36 (327), 2013, s. 86–90. (In Russian)
Chernysh, A. V. «Morshanskij millioner»: iz istorii skopchestva v Tambovskoj gubernii vo vtoroj polovine XIX v. Provincial'nye nauchnye zapiski [Provincial Research Notes], no. 12, 2017, s. 52–57. (In Russian)
Chornyj, A. V. Suchasni teorii liderstva: zahal'nyj ohliad ta strukturna model'. Naukovi zapysky Natsional'noho universytetu «Ostroz'ka akademiia». Seriia «Ekonomika» [Scientific Notes of Ostroh Academy National University. Series “Economics”], no. 9(37), 2018, s. 78–84. (In Ukrainian)
Ciocan C. T. The Religious Leadership. The Holistic Society: Multi-Disciplinary Perspectives. Proceedings of Harvard Square Symposium, no. 3, 2017, pp. 173–191.
Clay, E. Traders, Vagabonds, Incarnate Christs, and Pilgrims: The Religious Network of Danilo Filippov, 1650–1850. In: A. Scott, C. Kosso (eds.). Poverty and Prosperity in the Middle Ages and Renaissance. Turnhout, 2012, pp. 225–239.
Dal', V. I. Issledovanie o skopcheskoj eresi. Sankt-Peterburg, 1844. (In Russian)
Dmitrij (Rostovskij). Rozysk o raskol'nicheskoj Brynskoj vere. Moskva, 1847. (In Russian)
Dobronravov, V. G. Skopchestvo v predelah Vladimirskoj eparhii: (po mestnym arhivnym materialam). Vladimir, 1900. (In Russian)
Dobrotvorskij, I. Ljudi bozhii. Russkaja sekta tak nazyvaemyh duhovnyh hristian. Kazan', 1869. (In Russian)
Dokash, V. I. Sotsial'nyj kharakter eskhatolohii v apokaliptychnij ta prorochij literaturi. Relihiia ta Sotsium [Religion and Society], no. 3–4 (11–12), 2013, s. 179–188. (In Ukrainian)
Engelstein, L. Skopcy i Carstvo Nebesnoe. Moskva, 2002. (In Russian)
Etkind, A. M. Hlyst: sekty, literatura i revoljucija. Moskva, 1998. (In Russian)
Etkind, A. Russkie sekty vse eshhe kazhutsja «obscure». V: A. Etkind (red.). Non-fiction po-russki pravda. Kniga otzyvov. Moskva, 2007, s. 91–107. (In Russian)
Etkind, A. Whirling with the Other: Russian Populism and Religious Sects. The Russian Review, vol. 62, no. 4, 2003, pp. 565–588.
Goncharova, S. A. Vostochnoslavjanskie predstavlenija o klikushestve. Sborniki konferencij NIC Sociosfera [Collections of SIC Sociosphere conferences], no. 39, 2013, s. 13–18. (In Russian)
Horyn', H. J. Hromads'kyj pobut sil's'koho naselennia Ukrains'kykh Karpat (XIX — 30-ti roky XX st.). Kyiv, 1993. (In Ukrainian)
Ivlieva, Ya. A. Arkhivni dzherela schodo virovchennia pravoslavnykh sekt Tavrijs'koi hubernii u pershij polovyni ХІХ st. Naukovi pratsi istorychnoho fakul'tetu Zaporiz'koho natsional'noho universytetu [Scientific works of the Faculty of History of Zaporizhzhia National University], vyp. 38, 2014, c. 327–330. (In Ukrainian)
Kanat'eva, N. S. Astrahanskie hlystovskie obshhiny konca XIX — nachala XX vv. Kaspijskie region: politika, jekonomika, kul'tura [Caspian Region: Politics, Economy, Culture], no. 2(43), 2015, c. 400–406. (In Russian)
Kel'siev, V. I. Sbornik pravitel'stvennyh svedenij o raskol'nikah. London, 1860. (In Russian)
Kis', O. (red.). Zhinochi vymiry mynuloho: uiavlennia, dosvidy, reprezentatsii. L'viv, 2023. (In Ukrainian)
Kis', O. Koho oberihaie Berehynia, abo Matriarkhat iak cholovichyj vynakhid. «Ya» (Informatsijno-osvitnie vydannia) [“Ya” (Information and educational journal)], no. 4(16), 2006, s. 11–16. (In Ukrainian)
Klibanov, A. I. Istorija religioznogo sektantstva v Rossii (60-e g. XIX veka — 1917 g.). Moskva, 1965. (in Russian)
Kolodnyj, A. M. Fenomen relihii: pryroda, struktura, funktsional'nist', tendentsii. Kyiv, 1999. (In Ukrainian)
Kutepov, K. Sekty hlystov i skopcov. Stavropol', 1900. (In Russian)
Kuznecova, V. S. Legendy o pereplyvajushhej reku Bogorodice v russkoj fol'klornoj Biblii. Kritika i semiotika [Critique and Semiotics], vyp. 16, 2012, s. 163–185. (In Russian)
Loskutova, D. N. K voprosu ob oderzhimosti i nervnoj isterii v narodnyh predstavlenijah zhitelej Tambovskoj oblasti. Slavjanskij Mir [Slavonic World], no. 2(11), 2019, s. 424–436. (In Russian)
Mel'nikov-Pecherskij, P. I. Sobranie sochinenij v 8 tomah, t. 8. Moskva, 1976. (In Russian)
Mishhenko, V. V. Bytovye i gendernye osobennosti skopcheskih obshhin XIX v.: po materialam Orlovskoj gubernii. V: Gorozhanki i gorozhane v politicheskih, jekonomicheskih i kul'turnyh processah rossijskoj urbanizacii XIV — XXI vekov: mater. XXI mezhd. nauch. konf. Moskva, 2018, s. 141–154. (In Russian)
Moskalenko, L. M. Fenomen relihijnoho liderstva na prykladi iudejs'kykh tradytsij. Avtoreferat na zdobuttia naukovoho stupenia kandydata filosofs'kykh nauk. Kyiv, 2012. (In Ukrainian)
Muhina, Z. Vdova v russkoj krest'janskoj srede: tradicii i novacii (vtoraja polovina XIX — nachalo XX v.). Politika i obshhestvo [Politics and Society], no. 3(99), 2013, s. 322–329. (In Russian)
Nadezhdin, N. I. Issledovanie o skopcheskoj eresi. Sankt-Peterburg, 1845. (In Russian)
Nahorna, T. V. Dukhovni khrystyiany v Ukraini naprykintsi XVIII — u pershij polovyni XIX stolit'. Dysertatsiia na zdobuttia naukovoho stupenia kandydata istorychnykh nauk. Zaporizhzhia, 2007. (In Ukrainian)
Nelson, A. Reviewed Work: Castration and the Heavenly Kingdom: A Russian Folktale by Laura Engelstein. Russian History, vol. 27, no. 2, 2000, pp. 241–242.
Otrazitel'noe pisanie o novoizobretennom puti samoubijstvennyh smertej: vnov' najdennyj staroobrjadcheskij traktat protiv samosozhzhenija 1691 goda. Sankt-Peterburg, 1895. (In Russian)
Panchenko, A. A. Hristovshhina i skopchestvo: fol'klor i tradicionnaja kul'tura russkih misticheskih sekt. Moskva, 2004. (In Russian)
Panchenko, A. A. «Starye sekty» na novyj lad: problemy i perspektivy izuchenija russkih religioznyh dissidentov XVIII — XX vv. Gosudarstvo, religija, cerkov' v Rossii i za rubezhom [State, Religion, Church in Russia and Abroad], no. 38(3), 2020, c. 7–37. (In Russian)
Petrov, A. V. Vozniknovenie zhenskogo obshhestvenno-politicheskogo dvizhenija v Rossii i ego rol' v stanovlenii pravovogo statusa zhenshhin v dorevoljucionnyj period. Vestnik Nizhegorodskogo universiteta im. N. I. Lobachevskogo [Bulletin of N. I. Lobachevsky Nizhny Novgorod University], no. 13, 2011, s. 31–42. (In Russian)
Potots'kyj, V. P. Peresliduvannia sektantiv-mistykiv na Slobozhanschyni v umovakh svobody virospovidannia (1909–1917 rr.). Visnyk Kharkivs'koho natsional'noho universytetu imeni V. N. Karazina. Seriia «Istoriia Ukrainy. Ukrainoznavstvo: istorychni ta filosofs'ki nauky» [V. N. Karazin Kharkiv National University Bulletin ‘History of Ukraine. Ukrainian Studies: Historical and Philosophical Sciences’], vyp. 10, 2008, s. 75–81. (In Ukrainian)
Potots'kyj, V. P. Sekta skoptsiv u Bessarabii ta na Podilli (seredyna ХІХ — pochatok ХХ st.). Visnyk Kharkivs'koho natsional'noho universytetu imeni V. N. Karazina. Seriia «Istoriia Ukrainy. Ukrainoznavstvo: istorychni ta filosofs'ki nauky» [V. N. Karazin Kharkiv National University Bulletin ‘History of Ukraine. Ukrainian Studies: Historical and Philosophical Sciences’], vyp. 19, 2014, s. 62–68. (In Ukrainian)
Savchenko, S. V. Mistyky ta ratsionalisty: do klasyfikatsii sektants'kykh spil'not Ukrainy druhoi polovyny ХІХ – pochatku ХХ st. Visnyk Kharkivs'koho natsional'noho universytetu imeni V. N. Karazina. Seriia «Istoriia Ukrainy. Ukrainoznavstvo: istorychni ta filosofs'ki nauky» [V. N. Karazin Kharkiv National University Bulletin ‘History of Ukraine. Ukrainian Studies: Historical and Philosophical Sciences’], vyp. 20, 2015, s. 71–80. (In Ukrainian)
Sergazina, K. T. «Hozhdenie vkrug»: Ritual'naja praktika pervyh obshhin hristoverov. SanktPeterburg, 2017. (In Russian)
Sergazina, K. T. Ob Anne Stepanovoj, krest'janke Kostromskoj gubernii, pochitaemoj za Bogorodicu. Gosudarstvo, religija, cerkov' v Rossii i za rubezhom [State, Religion, Church in Russia and Abroad], no. 3, 2020, c. 63–83. (In Russian)
Shuhaieva, L. M. Pravoslavne sektantstvo v Ukraini: osoblyvosti transformatsii. Rivne, 2007. (In Ukrainian)
Sol'ev, E. N. Svedenija o russkih skopcah. Kostroma, 1870. (In Russian)
Stoglav. Kazan', 1862. (In Russian)
Todorova, S. M. Kontsept liderstva iak ob`iekt filosofs'koho analizu. Perspektyvy [Prospects], no. 2, 2015, s. 120–127. (In Ukrainian)
Varadinov, N. Istorija Ministerstva vnutrennih del. Kn. 8. Istorija rasporjazhenij po raskolu. Sankt-Peterburg, 1863. (In Russian)
Vysockij, N. G. Pervyj skopcheskij process. Materialy, otnosjashhiesja k nachal'noj istorii skopcheskoj sekty. Moskva, 1915. (In Russian)
Zabijako, A. O. Literaturnoe klikushestvo: Drama zhenskoj dushi i forma jetnoreligioznoj identifikacii. Religiovedenie [Religious studies], no. 1, 2010, s. 157–167. (In Russian)
Copyright (c) 2024 Pavlo Yeremieiev, Oleksandr Shevchenko
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.
Authors who publish with this journal agree to the following terms:
- Authors retain copyright and grant the journal right of first publication with the work simultaneously licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution License that allows others to share the work with an acknowledgement of the work's authorship and initial publication in this journal.
- Authors are able to enter into separate, additional contractual arrangements for the non-exclusive distribution of the journal's published version of the work (e.g., post it to an institutional repository or publish it in a book), with an acknowledgement of its initial publication in this journal.
- Authors are permitted and encouraged to post their work online (e.g., in institutional repositories or on their website) prior to and during the submission process, as it can lead to productive exchanges, as well as earlier and greater citation of published work (See The Effect of Open Access).
