The State and Confessional Life in Kharkiv Region on the Eve of the Great Terror (1934 – the Middle of 1937)
Abstract
The article is dedicated to religious life in Kharkiv region on the eve of The Great Terror and the influence of the Soviet state on it. The article analyzes the historiography of the issue under study, and concludes that despite the emergence of recent scientific works, which address various aspects of the functioning of individual religious denominations in Kharkiv region in the 1930s, the issue of reviving religious life in the region on the eve of The Great Terror unleashed by the totalitarian regime is still virtually out of sight of modern scientists and has not become an object of special study. Such processes as the believers’ reaction to the state’s activity, their resistance against the state’s oppression, the influence of the Constitution of 1936 on the religious circumstances, as well as the factors of religious life in Kharkiv province on the eve of the Great Terror have not been sufficiently studied yet. The article analyzes the conditions of religious denominations’ activity on the eve of the Great Terror. The influence of various factors on the revival of religious life is revealed. The different forms of manifestation of religious activity in Kharkiv region are elucidated. The article shows that the public discussion and adoption of the Constitution of 1936, which formally abolished the restrictions on the political rights of the clergy and proclaimed the freedom of conscience, resulted in increased activity of different groups of clergy and believers. The latter hoped for rapid normalization and liberalization of state-confessional relations. However, the revival took place in the situation when the previous practice of repression against members of various religious denominations and the closure of temples and prayer houses still continued. In these circumstances there were the different form of believers’ resistance and the defense of the religious rights which were decelerated by the laws. This activity of "the religious" did not go beyond the limits set by the current Soviet legislation and was generally aimed at ensuring freedom of conscience for citizens as proclaimed in the Constitution. In particular, this manifested itself in believers’ attempts to collect signatures to open churches closed (contrary to the existing law) by local authorities, and in numerous petitions and delegations to local and higher authorities, demanding that the prayer houses be returned to the religious communities. Religious communities actively also created various circles (choral singing, chess, etc.) in order to attract young people. There were appeals from the representatives of religious communities to consular offices of foreign countries for support against anti-religious harassment, etc. At the same time, the participation of believers (especially young people) in public worship and mass attendance of religious services, especially during church festivals, etc. intensified. The 1937 census revealed a high level of religiosity among the population (including the younger generation) which was conclusive proof of the failure of Stalin's “Godless Five-Year Plan.” Another important factor in stirring up religious life was the preparation and holding of elections to the Supreme Council of the USSR according to the new electoral laws, during which a fairly high level of self-organization of the clergy and believers were shown to the authorities, as well as their attempts to participate in the electoral race. It seriously frightened the nomenclature of the Soviet Communist Party, which perceived religion and the church as the institutions of the class enemies (according to their ideological paradigm). So they were regarding the state terror as the most effective method of struggle against the religion.
Downloads
References
Arhiv USBU v Kharkivs’kiy oblasti. Arhivno-kriminal’na sprava 01403 Garaschenko I. S. 63 ark. (In Russian)
Arhiv USBU v Kharkivs’kiy oblasti. sprava 035121 Arhivno-kriminal’na sprava 035121. Po obvineniu Lapi V. A.,Davidenko P. I., Pevnogo I. T. 276 ark. (In Russian)
Arhiv USBU v Kharkivs’kiy oblasti. Arhivno-kriminal’na sprava 037212. Po obvineniu Alperina M. V. E. po st. 54-4. 101 ark. (In Russian)
Babenko, L. Radyanski organi derzhavnoyi bezpeki v sistemi vzayemovidnosin derzhavi i pravoslavnoyi cerkvi v Ukrayini (1918 – seredina 1950-h rr.). Poltava, 2014. (In Ukrainian)
Bezbojnik, 21 serpnya, no. 8, 1937. (In Russian)
Central’niy Derzhavnyi Arhiv Gromads’kih Ob’ednan’ (CDAGO) Ucraini, f. 1, op. 20, spr. 7105, 39 ark. (In Russian)
Chefranov, O. Za yakist’ antyrelihiinoi roboty v shkoli. Bezvirnyk, no. 1, 1935, s. 11-15. (In Ukrainian)
Derzhavnyi arkhiv Kharkivs’koi oblasti (DAKhO), f. R-6452, op. 1, spr. 5740 (Letyaev I.I.20.07-27.12.1936 г.), 59 ark. (In Russian)
DAKhO, f. R-6452, op. 5, spr. 2427 (Po obvineniu Birt G. Y. 15.01-23.02.1934), 75 ark. (In Russian)
DAKhO, f. R-6452, op. 5, spr. 949 (Mayer A. F. 20.09.1936-10.06.1937), 159 ark. (In Russian)
DAKhO, f. R-6452. op. 4. spr. 2602 (Po obvineniu Nikonova I dr. po st. 54-10. 05.09.1936-07.06.1937), 256 ark. (In Russian)
DAKhO, f. R-6452, op. 4, spr. 3784 (Po obvineniu Ternovskogo A. M. 09-15.09.1937), 26 ark. (In Russian)
DAKhO, f. R-6452, op. 4, spr. 4064 (Po obvineniu Oleynika S. P. po st. 54-10), 53 ark. (In Russian)
DAKhO, f. P. 2, op.1, spr.712, 94 аrк. (In Russian)
DAKhO, f. P. 2, op. 1, spr. 260, 560 аrk. (In Russian)
DAKhO, f. P-3858. op. 2. spr. 51, 13 ark. (In Russian)
DAKhO, f. P-69, op. 1, spr. 252, 1079 ark. (In Russian)
DAKhO, f. P-69, op. 1, spr. 383, 213 ark. (In Russian)
DAKhO, f. P-2, op. 1, spr. 609, t. 1, 131 ark. (In Russian)
DAKhO, f. P-2, op. 1, spr. 610, 181 арк. (In Russian)
DAKhO, f. P-69, op. 1, spr. 611, т. 3, 148 арк. (In Russian)
DAKhO, f. P-69, op. 1, spr. 617, 157 аrк. (In Russian)
DAKhO, f. R-1606, op. 1, spr. 442, 202 арк. (In Russian)
DAKhO, f. P-69, op. 1, spr. 277, 591 ark. (In Russian)
DAKhO, f. P-3858, op. 6, spr. 13, 402 аrk. (In Russian)
DAKhO, f. P-3858, op. 6, spr. 10, 681 ark. (In Russian)
DAKhO, f. P-3858, op. 2, spr. 52, 8 ark. (In Russian)
Ignatuscha, O. Instituciyniy rozkol pravoslavnoi cerkvi v Ukraini: geneza i harakter (XIX st.-30-ti rr. XX st.). Zaporijjya, 2004. (In Ukrainian)
Ignatuscha, O. M., Savchuk, T. G. (upor.). Istoriya religiy: hrestomatiya-praktikum dliya studeniv vischih navchal’nih zakladiv. Zaporijjya, 2016. (In Ukrainian)
Istoriya radyanskoyi konstituciyi. Kiyiv, 1937. (In Ukrainian)
Fedoseev, P. Tovarisch Stalin o bor’be s religiey. Pod znamenem marksizma, no. 1, 1938, s. 13-33. (In Russian)
Fitzpatrick, S. Povsednevniy stalinizm. Social’naya istoriya sovetskoy Rossii v 30-e godi:gorod. Moskva, 2008. (In Russian)
Galevich Dimitriy, prot. Nezaareschtovani listi. Listi svyaschennika z Ukraini do Nimechchini 1922–1938. B.m., 2001. (In Ukrainian)
Gorvat, M. (a). Sektantske kublo v Tsyrkunakh. Bezvirnyk, no. 1, 1935, s. 28-30. (In Ukrainian)
Gorvat, M. (b). Pro antireligiynu robotu v Harkivskiy primis’kiy smuzi. Bezvirnik, no. 2-3, 1935, s. 68-69. (In Ukrainian)
Kalinina, A. Hristianskie konfessii sovetskoy Belorussii v 1929-1939 gg.:aktivnie i passivnie formi soprotivleniya. Gosudarstvo, religiya,cerkov’ v Rossii I zarubegom [State, Religion, Church in Russia and Abroad], no. 3-4 (30), 2012, s.181-202. (In Russian)
Konstituciya (osnovnoy zakon) SRSR. V: Istoriya sovetskoy Konstitucii. Zbornik dokumentov.1917–1957. Moskva, 1957. (In Russian)
Kravchenko, P., Sitarchuk, R. Protestantski ob'yednannya v Ukrayini v konteksti socialnoyi politiki bilshovikiv (20-30 ti roki ХХ stolittya). Poltava, 2005. (In Ukrainian)
Krasnov-Levitin, A. E. Likhiye gody. 1925–1941: Vospominaniya. Paris, 1977. (Іn Russian)
Kudelko, S., Pavlova, O., Schvec (o.Vladimir). Arhipastiri Khar’kovskoy eparhii (1799–1999). Khar’kov, 1999. (Іn Russian)
Kul’chickiy, S. V. Chervoniy viklik. Kn.2. Kyev, 2013. (In Ukrainian)
Martirologiya ukrayinskih cerkov. T. 1. Ukrayinska pravoslavna cerkva. Dokumenti, materiali. Toronto, Baltimor, 1987. (In Ukrainian)
Маtеriаli fеvrаl’skо-mаrtоvskоgо plеnumа CK VКP(b) 1937gоdа. V: Vорrоsi istоrii [Issues of history], no. 5, 1993, s. 3-23; no. 7, s. 3-24. (In Russian)
Matvienko, M. Istoriya Khar’kovskoy eparhii (1850–2013). Khar’kov, 2021. (In Russian)
Odincov, M. I. Gosudarstvo i cerkov 1917–1938 gg. Moskva, 1991. (In Russian)
Paschenko, V., Kyrydon, A. Bilshovicka derjava I pravoslavna cerkva v Ukraini. 1917–1930-ti roki. Poltva, 2004. (In Ukrainian)
Petrova, I. Politicheskoe nedomislie. Khar’kovskiy rabochiy, 13 noyabrya, no. 262 (1162), 1937. (In Russian)
Russkaya pravoslavnaya cerkov i kommunisticheskoe gosudarstvo. 1917–1941: Dokumenti i fotomateriali. Moskva, 1996. (In Russian)
Shlihta, N. Cerkva tih, hto vijiv. Radyans’ka Ukraina, seredina 1940-h – pochatok 1970-h rr. Harkiv, 2011. (In Ukrainian)
Socialistichna Kharkivschina, 3 chervniya, no. 124 (4855), 1937. (In Ukrainian)
Такеr, R. Stalin u vlasti.1928–1941. Istoriya i lichnost’. Moskva, 1997. (In Russian)
Velikanova, O. Konstitutsiya 1936 goda i massovaya politicheskaya kultura stalinizma. Moskva, 2021. (In Russian)
Velikiy terror v Ukraini: «Kurkul’ska operaciya» 1937–1938 rr. U 2-h ch. Ch.I. Kyev, 2010. (In Ukrainian)
Velikiy terror v Ukraini: «Kurkul’ska operaciya» 1937–1938 rr. U 2-h ch. Ch.II. Kyev, 2010. (In Ukrainian)
Yevgen’ev, M. (a). Rozgromiti pidstupi mrakobisiv. Bezbojnik, 11 sichnya, no. 2 (93), 1939. (In Ukrainian)
Yevgen’ev, M. (b). Schkidliva blagoduschnist’. Bezbozhnik, 17 sichnya, no. 3 (94), 1939. (In Ukrainian)
Zibrannya uzakonen’ i rozporyadjen’ robitnichogo I selyans’kogo yuryadu (ZU) URSR, no. 30, st. 121, 1937 (Konstituciya (osnovnoy zakon) URSR). (In Ukrainian)
Copyright (c) 2022 Yurii Volosnyk
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.
Authors who publish with this journal agree to the following terms:
- Authors retain copyright and grant the journal right of first publication with the work simultaneously licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution License that allows others to share the work with an acknowledgement of the work's authorship and initial publication in this journal.
- Authors are able to enter into separate, additional contractual arrangements for the non-exclusive distribution of the journal's published version of the work (e.g., post it to an institutional repository or publish it in a book), with an acknowledgement of its initial publication in this journal.
- Authors are permitted and encouraged to post their work online (e.g., in institutional repositories or on their website) prior to and during the submission process, as it can lead to productive exchanges, as well as earlier and greater citation of published work (See The Effect of Open Access).