Rules for the Adjudication of Quarrels Occurring in the Officer Community: the Significance and Consequences of the Change in Dueling Legislation in 1894
Abstract
The article considers the Rules for the Adjudication of Quarrels Occurring in the Officer Community (1894), which changed the dueling law in the Russian Empire. According to the new ruling, all conflicts in officer circles were referred to the Courts of the Society of Officers. These courts were vested with the authority either to determine that reconciliation befit the dignity of the officer and the traditions of the unit, or to sanction a duel as the sole proper means of satisfying the injured honor. The purpose of this innovation, as explained in the journal The Russian Invalid, was to raise the general level of ideas about honor in the officer milieu. The Rules for the Adjudication of Quarrels Occurring in the Officer Community were in conflict with the Penal Code of 1885, which forbade duels to all citizens of the Russian Empire, including military personnel. This legal collision precluded the development of a full legislative framework for dueling; no official duel code was ever adopted. Accordingly, difficulties arose in the application of the Rules. In practice, this led to a proliferation of duels occurring for trivial reasons. The new dueling law gave rise to yet another contradiction. Duels involving civilians were still treated with severity and often incurred strict punishment. This created grounds for additional conflicts between civilians and members of the officer corps. Furthermore, the law of 1894 affected relations in the officer community. With the new powers acquired by the Courts of the Society of Officers, the emphasis was now placed not on the personal assessment of an incident, but on the corporate opinion of it. The conclusion notes that the dueling decree of 1894, aimed at raising the general level of ideas about honor in the officer community and bringing under control the established norms for defending personal honor, did not achieve the intended results.
Downloads
References
Vazhinskiy, S. F. 1912: Pravila poedinka. Sankt-Peterburg. (In Russian).
Важинский, С. Ф. 1912: Правила поединка. Санкт-Петербург.
Delo o Kirrotare i Stratanoviche, obvinyavshikhsya v uchastii v dueli Irkutskoy sudebnoy palatoy. 1910. GARF, F. 124, Op. 28, D. 286. (In Russian).
Дело о Кирротаре и Стратановиче, обвинявшихся в участии в дуэли Иркутской судебной палатой. 1910: ГАРФ, Ф. 124, Оп. 28, Д. 286.
Delo po prosheniyu o pomilovanii Gilevicha V. A., osuzhdyennogo Novocherkasskoy sudebnoy palatoy za ubiystvo na dueli. 1909: GARF, F. 124, Op. 66, D. 84. (In Russian).
Дело по прошению о помиловании Гилевича В. А., осуждённого Новочеркасской судебной палатой за убийство на дуэли. 1909: ГАРФ, Ф. 124, Оп. 66, Д. 84.
Distsiplinarnyy ustav. 1895. Sankt-Peterburg. (In Russian).
Дисциплинарный устав. 1895. Санкт-Петербург.
Dragomirov, M. 1900: Dueli. Kiev. (In Russian).
Драгомиров, М. 1900: Дуэли. Киев.
Durasov, V. 1912: Duel’nyy kodeks. Sankt-Peterburg. (In Russian).
Дурасов, В. 1912: Дуэльный кодекс. Санкт-Петербург.
Zayonchkovskiy, P. A. 1973: Samoderzhavie i russkaya armiya na rubezhe XIX – XX stoletiy. Moskva. (In Russian).
Зайончковский, П. А. 1973: Самодержавие и русская армия на рубеже XIX-XX столетий. Москва.
Kireev, A. 1899: Pis’ma o poedinkakh. Sankt-Peterburg. (In Russian).
Киреев, А. 1899: Письма о поединках. Санкт-Петербург.
Kuprin, A. I. 1971: Poedinok. Sobranie sochineniy v 9 t. T. 4. Moskva. (In Russian).
Куприн, А. И. 1971: Поединок. Собрание сочинений в 9 т. Т. 4. Москва.
Korolenko, V. G. 1914: Russkaya duel’ v poslednie gody. Polnoe sobranie sochineniy v 9 t. T. 4, 296-302. Sankt-Peterburg. (In Russian).
Короленко, В. Г. 1914: Русская дуэль в последние годы. Полное собрание сочинений в 9 т. Т. 4, 296-302. Санкт-Петербург.
Livenson. 1900: Poedinok v zakonodatel’stve i nauke. Sankt-Peterburg. (In Russian).
Ливенсон. 1900: Поединок в законодательстве и науке. Санкт-Петербург.
M. E. 1902: Duel’ I chest’ v istinnom osveshchenii. Sankt-Peterburg. (In Russian).
М. Э. 1902: Дуэль и честь в истинном освещении. Санкт-Петербург.
Mar’еnko, N. Yu. 2019: Pro et contra: diskussii o dueli v rossiyskoy publitsistike kontsa XIX – nachala XX vv. Visnyk Harkivs’kogo nacional’nogo universytytu imeni V. N. Karazina. Serija «Istorija». Vyp. 55, 14-22. (In Russian).
Марьенко, Н. Ю. 2019: Pro et contra: дискуссии о дуэли в российской публицистике конца XIX – начала XX вв. Вісник Харківського національного університету імені В. Н. Каразіна. Серія «Історія». Вип. 55, 14-22.
Mel’nikova, A. A. 2003: Duel’ v Rossii v kontekste yazykovoy spetsifiki. Yazyk i natsional’nyy kharakter. Vzaimosvyaz’ struktury yazyka I mental’nosti, 277-311. Sankt-Peterburg. (In Russian).
Мельникова, А. А. 2003: Дуэль в России в контексте языковой специфики. Язык и национальный характер. Взаимосвязь структуры языка и ментальности, 277-311. Санкт-Петербург.
Mikulin, I. 1912: Posobie dlya vedeniya del chesti v ofitserskoy srede. Sankt-Peterburg. (In Russian).
Микулин, И. 1912: Пособие для ведения дел чести в офицерской среде. Санкт-Петербург.
Polnoe sobranie zakonov v Rossiyskoy imperii. Sobr. 1. 1830: T. 5. Sankt-Peterburg. (In Russian).
Полное собрание законов в Российской империи. Собр. 1. 1830: Т. 5. Санкт-Петербург.
Polnoe sobranie zakonov v Rossiyskoy imperii. Sobr. 1. 1830: T. 22. Sankt-Peterburg. (In Russian).
Полное собрание законов в Российской империи. Собр. 1. 1830: Т. 22. Санкт-Петербург.
Polnoe sobranie zakonov v Rossiyskoy imperii. Sobr. 3. 1898: T. 14. Sankt-Peterburg. (In Russian).
Полное собрание законов в Российской империи. Собр. 3. 1898: Т. 14. Санкт-Петербург.
Protiv poedinkov. Otvet generalu Kireevu ober-ofitsera russkoy armii. 1900. Sankt-Peterburg. (In Russian).
Против поединков. Ответ генералу Кирееву обер-офицера русской армии. 1900. Санкт-Петербург.
Pushkin, A. S. 1928: Pis’ma v 3 t. T. 2. Moskva-Leningrad. (In Russian).
Пушкин, А. С. 1928: Письма в 3 т. Т. 2. Москва-Ленинград.
Reyfman, I. 2002: Ritualizovannaya agressiya: Duel’ v russkoy kul’ture I literature. Moskva. (In Russian).
Рейфман, И. 2002: Ритуализованная агрессия: Дуэль в русской культуре и литературе. Москва.
Suvorin, A. 1913: Duel’nyy kodeks. Sankt-Peterburg. (In Russian).
Суворин, А. 1913: Дуэльный кодекс. Санкт-Петербург.
Ulozhenie o nakazaniyakh ugolovnykh i ispravitel’nykh. 1845. Sankt-Peterburg. (In Russian).
Уложение о наказаниях уголовных и исправительных. 1845. Санкт-Петербург.
Shveykovskiy, P. A. 1912: Sud obshchestva ofitserov i duel’ v voyskakh rossiyskoy armii. Sankt-Peterburg. (In Russian).
Швейковский, П. А. 1912: Суд общества офицеров и дуэль в войсках российской армии. Санкт-Петербург.
Copyright (c) 2019 Marienko M. Yu.
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.
Authors who publish with this journal agree to the following terms:
- Authors retain copyright and grant the journal right of first publication with the work simultaneously licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution License that allows others to share the work with an acknowledgement of the work's authorship and initial publication in this journal.
- Authors are able to enter into separate, additional contractual arrangements for the non-exclusive distribution of the journal's published version of the work (e.g., post it to an institutional repository or publish it in a book), with an acknowledgement of its initial publication in this journal.
- Authors are permitted and encouraged to post their work online (e.g., in institutional repositories or on their website) prior to and during the submission process, as it can lead to productive exchanges, as well as earlier and greater citation of published work (See The Effect of Open Access).
