One Name, One Person: The Problem of Reconstructing the List of Early Kings of Piedras Negras in Light of the Hieroglyphic Texts from Yaxchilan
Abstract
This article is concerned with an important episode in the early history of two neighboring kingdoms located in the western part of the Maya lowlands: Yaxchilan and Piedras Negras. The two sites were at war with each other and sought dominance in the Upper Usumacinta region for almost the entire duration of Classic Maya history (3rd to 10th centuries AD). The article examines some controversial issues related to the founding of the Yaxchilan and Piedras Negras dynasties and highlights the initial stage of their military confrontation, which took place in the second half of the 5th century. It is shown that the founders of both royal houses were probably of non-local origin, having arrived in their new capitals from elsewhere. The main sources used in this work are hieroglyphic inscriptions from Yaxchilan: lintels 11, 35, 37, and 49 and Hieroglyphic Stairway 1. These texts contain a list of local kings and a brief description of their military triumphs. In particular, it is mentioned that Jatz’oom Jol, the seventh ruler of Yaxchilan, and his successor Yaxuun Bahlam II gained victories over Piedras Negras and seized important captives. A ruler of Piedras Negras called Itzam K'an Ahk is mentioned in connection with both wars. Jatz’oom Jol captured Itzam K'an Ahk himself in the second half of the 450s at the earliest, and Yaxuun Bahlam II captured a military commander who served Itzam K'an Ahk in the late 460s or 470s. The opinion that two different rulers who successively sit on the throne of Piedras Negras, Itzam K'an Ahk I ("Ruler A") and Itzam K'an Ahk II ("Ruler B"), are mentioned on the Yaxchilan triumphal monuments is firmly established in historiography. However, having two successive Maya kings with the same name on the throne would have run contrary to the established practice of changing regnal names: the direct heir to the throne never repeated the name of their predecessor in the history of Yaxchilan and Piedras Negras. Besides that, the monuments from Yaxchilan only mention the capture of the enemy king, not his death. Maya history is replete with examples of defeated rulers returning home after being captured and ruling their kingdoms for many more years. This is what may have happened to Itzam K'an Ahk I. However, there is a plausible explanation for his being mentioned twice that is even simpler. Subordinate rulers and dignitaries in Classic Maya society maintained a personal relationship with their overlords even after the death of the latter. A military commander from Piedras Negras could remain a man of Itzam K'an Ahk I even if his suzerain had died in captivity long before the second war. Therefore, there are no sufficient grounds for distinguishing between the early Piedras Negras kings Itzam K'an Ahk I and Itzam K'an Ahk II. It is much more likely that the same person, namely the enemy king Itzam K'an Ahk I, is mentioned in the inscriptions in Yaxchilan and the list of rulers of Piedras Negras requires correction.
Downloads
References
Beliaev, D. D. Formirovanie i razvitie gosudarstvennoj organizacii u maya Petena v klassicheskij period (I tys. n. e'.): dis. … kandidata ist. nauk. Moskva, 2001. (In Russian)
Beliaev, D. D. Istoriya maya v klassicheskij period: obshhij ocherk. Mesoamerika glazami russkih pervoprohodcev, 2003, https://web.archive.org/web/20101122170312/, http://www.mezoamerica.ru/indians/maya/maya-hist.html. Data perehliadu: 15 zhovtnia 2022. (In Russian)
Beliaev, D. D., Safronov, A. V. Dinasticheskaya istoriya Yokiba vo vtoroj polovine VIII v. V sb.: A. G. Avdeev (Otv. red.), Voprosy e'pigrafiki. Vypusk 7. Chast' 1. Moskva, 2013, s. 533-599. (In Russian)
Berlin, H. El glifo “emblema” en las inscripciones mayas. Jornal de la Société des Americanistes, №47, 1958, pp. 111-119.
Bernal, G. Glifos Enigmáticos de la Escritura Maya: El logograma T514, YEJ, “filo”. Arqueología Mexicana, №135, 2015, pp. 78-85.
Biro, P. The Classic Maya Western Region: A History. Oxford, 2011.
Coe, M. Breaking the Maya Code. London and New York, 1992.
Escobedo, H., Houston, S. Arqueología e historia en Piedras Negras, Guatemala: síntesis de las temporadas de campo de 1997-2000. En: J.P. Laporte, H. Escobedo y B. Arroyo (editado), XV Simposio de Investigaciones Arqueológicas en Guatemala, 2001. Ciudad de Guatemala, 2002, pp. 135-144.
Graham, I., von Euw E. Corpus of Maya Hieroglyphic Inscriptions, Volume 3, Part 1: Yaxchilan. Cambridge, MA, 1977.
Graham, I. Corpus of Maya Hieroglyphic Inscriptions, Volume 3, Part 2: Yaxchilan. Cambridge, MA, 1979.
Grube, N. Palenque in the Maya World. In: M. Macri, J. McHargue (eds.), Eighth Palenque Round Table, 1993. San Francisco, 1996, pp. 1-13.
Grube, N. Volcanoes and Jungle – A Richly Varied Habitat. In: N. Grube (ed.), Maya: Divine Kings of the Rain Forest. Köln, 2001, pp. 21-31.
Grube, N. Onomástica de los gobernantes mayas. En: V. Tiesler, R. Cobos y M. G. Robertson (editado), La organización social entre los mayas prehispánicos, coloniales y modernos: Memoria de la Tercera Mesa Redonda de Palenque, Vol. II. Mexico y Merida, 2002, pp. 323-353.
Grube, N., Martin, S. The Coming of Kings: Writing and Dynastic Kingship in the Maya Area between the Late Preclassic and the Early Classic. Notebook for the XXV Maya Hieroglyphic Forum. Austin, 2001.
Helmke, C., Awe, J. Death Becomes Her: An Analysis of Panel 3, Xunantunich, Belize. The PARI Journal, Vol. 16 №4, 2016a, pp. 1-14.
Helmke, C., Awe, J. Sharper than a Serpent's Tooth: A Tale of the Snakehead Dynasty as Recounted on Xunantunich Panel 4. The PARI Journal, Vol. 17 №2, 2016b, pp. 1-22.
Houston, S. Hieroglyphs and History at Dos Pilas: Dynastic Politics of the Classic Maya. Austin, 1993.
Houston, S. The Epigraphy of El Zotz. Mesoweb Articles, 2008, http://www.mesoweb.com/ zotz/articles/ZotzEpigraphy.pdf. Accessed: 10 Dec. 2022.
Houston, S., Escobedo, H., Child, M., Golden, Ch., Muñoz, R. The Moral Community: Maya Settlement Transformation at Piedras Negras, Guatemala. In: M. Smith (ed.), The Social Construction of Ancient Cities. Washington D.C, 2003, pp. 212–253.
Houston, S., Garrison, T., Román E. A Fortress in Heaven: Researching the Long Term at El Zotz, Guatemala. In: T. Garrison, S. Houston (eds.), An Inconstant Landscape: The Maya Kingdom of El Zotz, Guatemala. Louisville, 2018, pp. 3–45.
Houston, S., Inomata, T. The Classic Maya. Cambridge, UK and New York, 2009.
Knorozov, Yu. V. Drevnyaya pis'mennost' Central'noj Ameriki. Sovetskaya e'tnografiya, № 3, 1952, s. 100-118. (In Russian)
Kováč, M. The Messages of Maya Ruins: Six Years of Research of the Slovak Archaeological Project in Guatemala (2009–2014). Supplement of Historická Revue, Vol. 25 № 10, 2014, pp. 1-28.
Lacadena, A. Titulos militares en los textos jeroglificos mayas del periodo clasico. Ponencia presentada en 8 Congreso internacional de mayistas. Ciudad de Mexico, 2010.
Looper, M., Polyukhovych Y. A Familial Relationship Between Nobles of El Peru (Waka') and El Zotz (Pa'chan) as Recorded on a Polychrome Vessel. Glyph Dwellers, Report 47, 2016, http://glyphdwellers.com/pdf/R47.pdf. Accessed: 10 Dec. 2022.
Looper, M., Polyukhovych Y. Four Painted Vessels in the Nasher Museum of Art at Duke University. Glyph Dwellers, Report 81, 2022, http://glyphdwellers.com/pdf/R81.pdf. Accessed: 15 Nov. 2022.
Martin, S. In Line of the Founder: A View of Dynastic Politics at Tikal. In: J. Sabloff (ed.), Tikal: Dynasties, Foreigners, and Affairs of State. Santa Fe and Oxford, 2003, pp. 3-45.
Martin, S. A Broken Sky: The Ancient Name of Yaxchilan as Pa’ Chan. The PARI Journal, Vol. 5, №1, 2004a, pp. 1-7.
Martin, S. Preguntas epigráficas acerca de los escalones de Dzibanché. En: E. Nalda (ed.), Los cautivos de Dzibanché. Ciudad de Mexico, 2004b, pp. 104-115.
Martin, S. Ideology and the Early Maya Polity. In: L. Traxler, R. Sharer (eds.), Origins of Maya States. Philadelphia, 2016, pp. 507-544.
Martin, S. Ancient Maya Politics: A Political Anthropology of the Classic Period 150–900 CE. Cambridge, 2020.
Martin, S., Grube, N. Chronicle of the Maya Kings and Queens: Deciphering the Dynasties of the Ancient Maya. London and New York, 2008.
Martin, S., Skidmore, J. Exploring the 584286 Correlation between the Maya and European Calendars. The PARI Journal, Vol. 13 №2, 2012, pp. 3-16.
Martin S., Velasquez E. Polities and Places: Tracing the Toponyms of the Snake Dynasty. The PARI Journal, Vol. 17 №2, 2016, pp. 23-33.
Martin, S., Zender, M., Grube, N. Palenque and Its Neighbors. Notebook for the XXVI Maya Hieroglyphic Forum. Austin, 2002.
Mathews, P. The Sculpture of Yaxchilan. Ph.D. dissertation. Yale University, New Haven, 1988.
Mathews, P. Classic Maya Emblem Glyphs. In: P. Culbert (ed.), Classic Maya Political History: Hieroglyphic and Archaeological Evidence. Cambridge, 1991, pp. 19-29.
Miller, M., Martin, S. Courtly Art of the Ancient Maya. London and New York, 2004.
Nahm, W. Hieroglyphic Stairway 1 at Yaxchilan. Mexicon, Vol. 19 №4, 1997, pp. 65-69. Nahm, W. New Readings on Hieroglyphic Stairway 1. Mexicon, Vol. 28 №2, 2006, pp. 28-39.
Polyukhovych, Yu. Yu. Polityko-dynastychna istoriia derzhavy maya Baakal' za materialamy korpusu epihrafichnykh dzherel Palenque (Lakamha'): dys. … kandydata ist. nauk. Kyiv, 2012. (In Ukrainian)
Polyukhovych Y., Styuflyaev M. Between Scylla and Charybdis: Wars of Santa Elena with Palenque and Snake Kingdom in the Sixth and Seventh Centuries. Glyph Dwellers, Report 64, 2020.
Safronov, A. V. Gosudarstva maya Zapadnogo regiona v klassicheskij period: dis. … kandidata ist. nauk. Moskva, 2006. (In Russian)
Sánchez A., Polyukhovych Y., Cuevas M., Herbert L., Krempel G. The Hieroglyphic Stairway of House C, Palenque, Chiapas: New Approaches. Mexicon, Vol. 42 №1, 2020, pp. 7-11.
Schele, L. An Epigraphic History of the Western Maya Region. In: P. Culbert (ed.), Classic Maya Political History: Hieroglyphic and Archaeological Evidence. Cambridge, 1991, pp. 72-101.
Schele, L., Mathews, P. Royal Visits and Other Intersite Relationships among the Classic Maya. In: P. Culbert (ed.), Classic Maya Political History: Hieroglyphic and Archaeological Evidence. Cambridge, 1991, pp. 226-252.
Stadnik, M. A. Mezoamerykans'ki kodeksy XIII–XVI stolittia: istoryko-kul'turne znachennia ta problemy rekonstruktsii: kvalifikatsijna robota mahistra. Kyiv, 2022. (In Ukrainian)
Stuart, D. A Study of Maya Inscriptions. PhD Dissertation. Vanderbilt University, Nashville, 1995.
Stuart, D. Una guerra entre Yaxchilán y Piedras Negras? En: H. Escobedo y S. Houston (editado), Proyecto Arqueológico Piedras Negras, informe preliminar no. 2, segunda temporada, 1998. Ciudad de Guatemala, 1999, pp. 389-392.
Stuart, D. Longer Live the King: The Questionable Demise of K'inich K'an Joy Chitam of Palenque. The PARI Journal, Vol. 4 № 1, 2003, pp. 1-4.
Stuart, D. The Paw Stone: The Place Name of Piedras Negras, Guatemala. The PARI Journal, Vol. 4 №3, 2004, pp. 1-6.
Stuart, D. Inscriptions of the River Cities: Yaxchilan, Piedras Negras and Pomona. Sourcebook for the XXXI Maya Meetings. Austin, 2007.
Stuart, D. The Order of Days: The Maya World and the Truth about 2012. New York, 2011. Stuart, D., Houston, S. Classic Maya Place Names. Washington D.C., 1994.
Styuflyaev, M. I. Kalendar' maya: obshhie svedeniya. V sb.: Prirozhdennye mastera. Moskva, 2019, s. 140-185. (In Russian)
Styuflyaev, M. I. Istoriia i propahanda v napysakh tsaria Yaxchilana Yaxuun Bahlama IV. U zb: O. Mashevs'kyj (red.), USL Science II: naukovyj zbirnyk materialiv konferentsij (Kyiv, 2022). Odesa, 2023, s. 49-57. (In Ukrainian)
Talakh, V. M. Vstup do ierohlifichnoi pysemnosti maya. Kyiv, 2019. (In Ukrainian)
Thompson, E. Maya Hieroglyphic Writing: An Introduction. Washington D.C., 1950. Thompson, E. A Catalog of Maya Hieroglyphs. Norman, 1962.
Tokovinine, A. People from a Place: Re-Interpreting Classic Maya Emblem Glyphs. In: C. Isendahl, B. L Persson (eds.), Ecology, Power, and Religion in Maya Landscapes. Acta Mesoamericana, Vol. 23. Markt Schwaben, 2011, pp. 91-106.
Tokovinine, A. Place and Identity in Classic Maya Narratives. Washington D.C, 2013.
Tokovinine, A. Fire in the Land: Landscapes of War in Classic Maya Narratives. In: S. Morton, M. Peuramaki-Brown (eds.), Seeking Conflict in Mesoamerica: Operational, Cognitive, and Experiential Approaches. Louisville, 2019, pp. 77-100.
Zender, M. The Toponyms of El Cayo, Piedras Negras, and La Mar. In: A. Stone (ed.), Heart of Creation: The Mesoamerican World and the Legacy of Linda Schele. Tuscaloosa, 2002, pp. 166-184.
Authors who publish with this journal agree to the following terms:
- Authors retain copyright and grant the journal right of first publication with the work simultaneously licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution License that allows others to share the work with an acknowledgement of the work's authorship and initial publication in this journal.
- Authors are able to enter into separate, additional contractual arrangements for the non-exclusive distribution of the journal's published version of the work (e.g., post it to an institutional repository or publish it in a book), with an acknowledgement of its initial publication in this journal.
- Authors are permitted and encouraged to post their work online (e.g., in institutional repositories or on their website) prior to and during the submission process, as it can lead to productive exchanges, as well as earlier and greater citation of published work (See The Effect of Open Access).
