INITIATING OF A REFERENDUM AS THE INITIAL STAGE OF THE REFERENDUM PROCESS
Abstract
Introduction. People's power, represented by the two direct forms provided for by the Constitution of Ukraine, acts as one of the foundations of the constitutional order in Ukraine. This fact, combined with the long-term absence of the practice of holding referendums, actualizes any research devoted to the issues of referendum legislation.
In contrast to the theoretical aspects of the right to a referendum, the issues of the referendum process are investigated rather secondary and not so intensively. Individual stages of the referendum procedure are not clearly regulated, or the norms are formulated in a discretionary manner, which puts the possibility of their application in one form or another, depending on the discretion of representative and other state authorities. At the same time, the very formation of a theoretical basis in relation to individual stages of the referendum process can further encourage the legislator to solve the problems of legal regulation that will be revealed during the formation of this basis, as well as act as a theoretical springboard for further research in the field of people's power and procedural forms of its implementation.
Summary of the main results of the study.In modern theoretical jurisprudence, stagedness (structuredness) is a generally recognized property of any procedural form of activity, although the issues of the general list of stages, their content and demarcation criteria are still debatable. Moreover, legal theorists have not developed a universally recognized concept of the stage of the legal process, and that is why there is often a mechanical transfer of formed ideas about stages from branch legal sciences to the general theory of law and vice versa. However, the structure of the legal process traditionally includes proceedings, stages, stages and procedural actions.
Referendum process is one of the constitutional forms of the legal process, and therefore it is also fully inherent in stagedness. Traditional for domestic constitutional and legal doctrine is the separation of three main stages of the referendum (more precisely, the referendum process) proposed by V. Pohorilko and V. Fedorenko: preparatory (referendum preparation), main (referendum holding) and final (referendum summary). Under this approach, initiation is considered as an element of the preparatory stage.
Such a "traditional" approach looks quite reasonable and logical. Indeed, the holding of a referendum requires significant preparation: starting from the formation of the very idea about the need to hold a vote on a certain issue to its submission to the discretion of the voting participants. However, this approach somewhat artificially combines procedural actions that differ in their content and specific purpose. In addition, the name of the first of the main stages does not look good enough, since preparation is required for any procedural action within the referential process, not only those performed at the initial stage.
Conclusions. Initiation is an independent, initial stage of any referendum process, regardless of the type of referendum. The purpose of this stage is to ensure proper and sufficient factual circumstances for the appointment of the relevant referendum. The content of the initiation stage covers the procedural stages and actions related to the identification of the subjects of initiation, the determination of the legality of the subject of the referendum and the jurisdiction of its formula. The initiation stage is a mandatory stage of the referendum process, regardless of the subject of initiation and the degree of obligation to hold the referendum. The referendum process should be considered started from the moment the referendum initiation stage begins. The same initiation should be considered started not from the moment of the desire to hold a referendum on the part of state bodies, representative authorities or citizens endowed with the right to participate in referendums, but from the moment of its legal fixation. The end of the initiation stage should be considered the moment of occurrence or, on the contrary, the impossibility of occurrence (in particular, due to the expiration of the time limits for overcoming legal barriers, the recognition of the issue initiated by the referendum as unconstitutional, etc.) of legal grounds for the appointment or proclamation of a referendum.
Downloads
References
/References
Конституція України від 28.06.1996. URL: https://zakon.rada.gov.ua/laws/show/254к/96-вр#Text (дата звернення:26.10.2024).
Панкевич О. З., БаранМ. В. Референдум як інститут демократії: уроки для України. Матеріали І Всеукраїнського науково-практичного семінару. Житомир. 2020. С. 89-92. URL: https://conf.ztu.edu.ua/wp-content/uploads/2020/12/pravova-polityka.pdf(дата звернення:26.10.2024).
Слинько Д.В. Юридичний процес: історія, теорія, практика: монографія. Харків: НТМТ, 2017. 415 с.
Рябченко Т. О. Поняття та стадії референдного правотворчого процесу в Україні. Науковий часопис Національного педагогічного університету імені М. П. Драгоманова. Серія 18 : Економіка і право. 2013. Вип. 22. С. 235-243.URL: http://enpuir.npu.edu.ua/handle/123456789/25846(дата звернення:26.10.2024).
Федоренко В. Референдне право в системі конституційного права. Вісник Центральної виборчої комісії. 2005. № 2. С. 72-76.URL: https://cvk.gov.ua/visnik-tsentralnoi-viborchoi-komisii.html(датазвернення:26.10.2024).
Про всеукраїнський та місцеві референдуми: Закон України від 03.07.1991 № 1286-ХІІ. URL: https://zakon.rada.gov.ua/laws/show/1286-12#Text(дата звернення:26.10.2024).
Федоренко В.Л. Принципи і порядок проведення референдумів в Україні. Конституційне право України. Академічний курс: підручник. У 2 т. Т.2 / за заг. ред. Ю.С. Шемшученка. Київ: Юридична думка, 2008. С. 226-250.
Погорілко В. Ф., Федоренко В. Л. Референдне право України: навч. посібник. Київ: Ліра, 2009. 366 с.
Шаповал В. Д. Слободяник Т.М., Літвяков Е. М. Законодавче регулювання референдуму в Україні. Науковий вісник Ужгородського університету. Серія: Право. 2023. Вип. 77. Т. 1. С. 136-142. DOI:https://doi.org/10.24144/2307-3322.2023.77.1.21 (дата звернення:26.10.2024).
Чебаненко О.Д., Грищук О.Ю., Колодяжна Н.В., Євгеньєва А.М. Референдуми в Європейському Союзі / за ред. Д.С. Ковриженка. Київ: ФАДА, ЛТД, 2007. 186 с.
Книгін К. Г. Процесуальні аспекти всеукраїнського референдуму. Актуальні проблеми держави і права. 2004. Вип. 22. С. 239-243. URL: http://nbuv.gov.ua/UJRN/apdp_2004_22_45 (дата звернення:26.10.2024).
Про всеукраїнський референдум: Закон України від 06.11.2012 № 5475-VI. URL: https://zakon.rada.gov.ua/laws/show/5475-17#Text(дата звернення:26.10.2024).
Ставнійчук А. П. Місцевий референдум як форма безпосереднього здійснення муніципальної влади територіальною громадою : дис. ... канд. юрид. наук : 12.00.02. Київ, 2017. 240 с.
McKay S. Building a Better Referendum: Linking Mini-Publics and Mass Publics in Popular Votes.Journalof Public Deliberation. 2019. Vol. 15. Issue 1. P. 1-29. DOI: https://doi.org/10.16997/jdd.319 (дата звернення:26.10.2024).
Hendriks F.,Wagenaar C. The Deliberative Referendum: An Idea Whose Time has Come? Administration & Society. 2023. Vol. 55.Issue 3.P. 569-590. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1177/00953997221140898 (дата звернення:26.10.2024).
Kenny D., KavanaghA. Are the People the Masters? Constitutional Referendums in Ireland. The Limits and Legitimacy of Referendums / R. Albert, R. Stacey (еd.) Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2022. Р. 264-292. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1093/oso/9780198867647.001.0001 (дата звернення:26.10.2024).
TierneyS. The Referendum in Multi-level States: Fracturing or Fostering Federal Models of Government? Federal Idea: A Quebec Think Tank on Federalism.Quebec. 2014. URL: http://ideefederale.ca/documents/Tierney_ang.pdf(дата звернення:26.10.2024).
Zavadskaya M.,Kersting N.,Magne T. Direct democracy integrity in modern authoritarian systems. The constitutional referendum in Turkey 2017 and Russian plebiscite in 2020. Politics of the Low Countries. 2023.Vol. 5. № 1. Р. 90-110. URL: https://www.elevenjournals.com/tijdschrift/PLC/2023/1/PLC-D-22-00020 (дата звернення:26.10.2024).
Про всеукраїнський референдум: ЗаконУкраїни від 26.01.2021 № 1135-IX. URL:https://zakon.rada.gov.ua/laws/show/1135-20#Text (дата звернення:26.10.2024).
Соколенко Ю. М., Кириченко В. М. Класифікація референдумів у Конституціях України та держав континентальної Європи: порівняльно-правовий аналіз. Актуальні проблеми міжнародного права. 2020. Вип. 23. С. 11-20. DOI:https://doi.org/10.32841/ILA.2020.23.02 (дата звернення:26.10.2024).
QvortrupM. ReferendumsinWestern Europe. Referendums Around the World / M. Qvortrup (eds). London: Palgrave Macmillan, 2014. P. 43-64. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1057/9781137314703_3 (дата звернення:26.10.2024).
Constitution of Ukraine dated June 28, 1996. URL: https://zakon.rada.gov.ua/laws/show/254к/96-вр#Text.
Pankevich O. Z., Baran M. V. (2020). Referendum as an institution of democracy: lessons for Ukraine.
Materials of the 1st All-Ukrainian Scientific and Practical Seminar. Zhytomyr. P. 89-92. URL:
https://conf.ztu.edu.ua/wp-content/uploads/2020/12/pravova-polityka.pdf (in Ukrainian).
Slinko D.V. (2017). Legal process: history, theory, practice: monograph. Kharkiv: NTMT. 415 p. (in
Ukrainian).
Ryabchenko T. O. (2013). The concept and stages of the referential law-making process in Ukraine. Scientific
journal of the M. P. Drahomanov National Pedagogical University. Series 18: Economy and law. Vol. 22. P. 235-243 (in
Ukrainian).
Fedorenko V. L. (2005). Referendum law in the system of constitutional law. Bulletin of the Central Election
Commission. No. 2. P. 72-76 (in Ukrainian).
On all-Ukrainian and local referenda: Law of Ukraine dated July 3, 1991 No. 1286-ХІ. URL:
https://zakon.rada.gov.ua/laws/show/1286-12#Text.
Fedorenko V.L. (2008). Principles and procedure of holding referendums in Ukraine. Constitutional law of
Ukraine. Academic course: textbook. In 2 volumes. Vol.2 / for general ed. Yu.S. Shemshuchenko. Kyiv: Yuridichna
Dumka. P. 226-250 (in Ukrainian).
Pohorilko V. F., Fedorenko V. L. (2009). Referendum law of Ukraine: education. manual. Kyiv: Lira. 366 p.
(in Ukrainian).
Shapoval V. D. Slobodianyk T.M., Litvyakov E. M. (2023). Legislative regulation of the referendum in
Ukraine. Scientific Bulletin of Uzhhorod University. Series: Law. Vol. 77. Issue 1. P. 136-142. DOI:
https://doi.org/10.24144/2307-3322.2023.77.1.21 (in Ukrainian).
Chebanenko O.D., Hryshchuk O.Yu., Kolodyazhna N.V., Yevgenyeva A.M. (2007). Referendums in the
European Union / edited by D.S. Kryvzhenko. Kyiv: FADA, LTD. 186 p. (in Ukrainian).
Knygin K. G. (2004). Procedural aspects of the all-Ukrainian referendum. Actual problems of the state and
law. Issue 22. P. 239-243. URL: http://nbuv.gov.ua/UJRN/apdp_2004_22_45 (in Ukrainian).
On the all-Ukrainian referendum: Law of Ukraine dated November 6, 2012 No. 5475-VI. URL:
https://zakon.rada.gov.ua/laws/show/5475-17#Text.
Stavniychuk A. P. (2017). Local referendum as a form of direct exercise of municipal power by a territorial
community: diss. ... candidate law sciences: 12.00.02. Kyiv. 240 p. (in Ukrainian).
McKay S. (2019). Building a Better Referendum: Linking Mini-Publics and Mass Publics in Popular Votes.
Journal of Public Deliberation. Vol. 15. Issue 1. P. 1-29. DOI: https://doi.org/10.16997/jdd.319.
Hendriks F., Wagenaar C. (2023). The Deliberative Referendum: An Idea Whose Time Has Come?
Administration & Society. Vol. 55. Issue 3. P. 569-590. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1177/00953997221140898.
Kenny D. Kavanagh A. (2022). Are the People the Masters? Constitutional Referendums in Ireland. The
Limits and Legitimacy of Referendums / R. Albert, R. Stacey (ed.). Oxford: Oxford University Press. P. 264-292. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1093/oso/9780198867647.001.0001
Tierney S. (2014). The Referendum in Multi-level States: Fracturing or Fostering Federal Models of
Government? Federal Idea: A Quebec Think Tank on Federalism. Quebec. URL:
http://ideefederale.ca/documents/Tierney_ang.pdf.
Zavadskaya M., Kersting N., Magne T. (2023). Direct democracy integrity in modern authoritarian systems.
The constitutional referendum in Turkey 2017 and Russian plebiscite in 2020. Politics of the Low Countries. Vol. 5. No.
P. 90-110. URL: https://www.elevenjournals.com/tijdschrift/PLC/2023/1/PLC-D-22-00020.
On the all-Ukrainian referendum: Law of Ukraine dated January 26, 2021 No. 1135-IX. URL:
https://zakon.rada.gov.ua/laws/show/1135-20#Text. (in Ukrainian).
Yu. Sokolenko. M., Kyrychenko V. M. (2020). Classification of referendums in the Constitutions of Ukraine
and the states of continental Europe: a comparative legal analysis. Actual problems of international law. Vol. 23. P. 11-
DOI: https://doi.org/10.32841/ILA.2020.23.02 (in Ukrainian).
Qvortrup M. (2014). Referendums in Western Europe. Referendums Around the World / M. Qvortrup (eds).
London: Palgrave Macmillan. P. 43-64. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1057/9781137314703_3.
Copyright (c) 2024 Андрій Куліш

This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.