THE FIRST “NO” TO EUROPE: THE UK’S REACTION TO THE SCHUMAN PLAN AND ITS CONSEQUENCES, 10 MAY – 3 JUNE 1950
Abstract
The study deals with the response of the United Kingdom to the Schuman Plan for a European Coal and Steel Community. It analyzes three key issues: the British attitude towards the French initiative, the London-Paris dialogue in May 1950, and the geopolitical dimensions of the UK’s decision not to participate in the first supranational community. The focus is on the reaction of Clement Attlee's Labour government and the diplomacy led by Ernest Bevin, as well as the solid bipartisan consensus on the issue of Europe. The political dimensions of the reasons and consequences of British actions as a conscious geopolitical choice and an act of self-determination come into the spotlight. After 1945 the United Kingdom was actively involved in the establishment of the first regional organizations in Western Europe: the Western Union, the Organization for European Economic Cooperation, and the Council of Europe, consistently advocating their intergovernmental character. Meanwhile, France showed a desire to depart from traditional frameworks and apply a new approach to effectively solve its economic and military security concerns against Germany. Disagreements over the application of the supranational method created an unbridgeable gap, given the intransigence of both sides. The British position was based on the lessons of the Second World War, an understanding of national sovereignty as a supreme value, prioritizing relations with the Commonwealth and the United States, the desire to maintain the status of a global power and a leading position in Europe through expanding intergovernmental cooperation rather than integration. As a result, London missed the unique opportunity to shape the fate of contemporary Europe, which would not be built around the historical Anglo-French Entente but on the union of former longtime foes, France and West Germany.
Downloads
References
/References
British communiquе on the Schuman Plan (3 June 1950), https://www.cvce.eu/en/recherche/unit-content/-/unit/02bb76df-d066-4c08-a58a-d4686a3e68ff/41502a9f-fd21-4e0e-b2ee-3ba63a2353d5/Resources#edf2e199-794a-4ea5-b8ad-9d0fd6576ad1_en&overlay (Date of application 25.09.2023)
Bullen, R. 1988. The British Government and the Schuman Plan, May 1950 – March 1951. In: Schwabe, Klaus (Hrsg). Die Anfдnge des Schuman – Plans, 1950–1951. The Beginnings of the Schuman Plan. Baden-Baden, NOMOS, pp. 199–210.
Bullock, A. 1983. Ernest Bevin: Foreign Secretary, 1945–1951. London, William Heinemann Ltd, 896 pp.
Conclusions of a Meeting of the Cabinet, 2 June 1950. https://www.cvce.eu/en/obj/conclusions_of_a_meeting_of_the_cabinet_on_the_refusal_to_participate_in_the_negotiations_on_the_schuman_plan_london_2_june_1950-en-8737a230-6924-4905-8004-dee4385ad38e.html (Date of application 23.09.2023)
DBPO. Documents on British Policy Overseas. 1986. Series II. Volume I: The Schuman Plan, the Council of Europe and Western European Integration, May 1950 – December 1952. Ed. by Bullen, Roger and Pelly, M. E. London, Her Majesty's Stationery Office.
Dell, Ed. 1995. The Schuman Plan and the British Abdication of Leadership in Europe. New York & Oxford University Press, 336 pp.
Douglas, R. M. 2004. The Labour Party, Nationalism, and Internationalism, 1939–1951. London, Routledge, 320 pp.
Hansard House of Commons Debates, 11 May 1950, Vol. 475, р. 587.
https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/1950-05-11/debates/67f015bb-a27e-4f68-935d-1dd917a9640a/CoalAndSteelProduction(IntegrationProposals)?highlight=schuman#contribution-75cbbc8f-68d7-4447-bb9e-dfa792094ac9 (Date of application 23.09.2023)
James, R. R. 1974. Winston S. Churchill, His complete speeches: 1897–1963. Volume VIII: 1950–1963. London and New York, Chelsea House Publishers and R. R. Bowker Company.
Kennan, G. F. 1983. Memoirs, 1925–1950. Washington, Pantheon Publ., 596 pp.
Kьsters, H. J. 1988. Die Verhandlungen ьber das institutionelle System zur Grьndung der Europдische Gemeinschaft fьr Kohle und Stahl. In: Schwabe, Klaus (Hrsg) Die Anfдnge des Schuman – Plans, 1950–195. The Beginnings of the Schuman Plan. Baden-Baden, NOMOS, pp. 73–102.
Labour Party. 1950. European Union. Brousher. London.
Lord, Chr. 1996. Absent at the Creation: Britain and the Formation of the European Community, 1950–1952. Dartmouth, 175 pp.
Lord, Chr. 1998. ’With but not of Europe’: Britain and the Schuman Plan. Journal of European Integration History. Vol. IV, issue 2, pp. 23–46.
Lynch, F. 1988. The Role of Jean Monnet in Setting up the European Coal and Steel Community. In: Schwabe, Klaus (Hrsg). Die Anfдnge des Schuman – Plans, 1950–1951. The Beginnings of the Schuman Plan. Baden-Baden, NOMOS, pp. 117–130.
Milward, Al. S. 1984. The Reconstruction of Western Europe, 1945–1951. London, Methuen, 527 pp.
Morgan, K. O. 1984. Labour in Power, 1945–1951. Oxford, Oxford University Press, 564 pp.
Parker, R. A. 1986. British Perceptions of Power. Europe between the Superpowers. In: Becker, Josef and Franz Knipping (eds). Power in Europe? Great Britain, France, Italy, and West Germany in a Postwar World, 1945–1950. Berlin, Walter de Gruyter, pp. 447–460.
Stirk, P. M. 1996. A History of European Integration Since 1914. New York, Pinter, 308 p.
Wurm, Cl. 1999. The Making of the European Community. Britain, Western Europe and European Integration, 1945–1957: The View from the Continent. European Review of History / Revue europйenne d'histoire. Vol. VI, issue 2, pp. 235–249.
Young, J. 1984. Britain, France, and the Unity of Europe, 1945–1951. London, Salem House Publ., 228 pp.
Стоянов, Б. 2022. Европа преди Европа: Проектите за Трета сила, Европейска федерация и Съединени европейски щати и тяхната съдба, 1945–1949 г. София, УИ „Св. Климент Охридски“, 326 с.
Шуман, Робер. 2001. За Европа. София, изд. „Книжен тигър“, 152 с.
Background Note No 132. Britain and the Franco German Steel and Coal Pool (The Hague, 20 May 1950), https://www.cvce.eu/en/recherche/unit-content/-/unit/02bb76df-d066-4c08-a58a-d4686a3e68ff/41502a9f-fd21-4e0e-b2ee-3ba63a2353d5/Resources#53bc62f2-8b3c-4e9a-a4bd-48f52fc79124_en&overlay (Date of application 28.09.2023)
British communiquе on the Schuman Plan (3 June 1950), https://www.cvce.eu/en/recherche/unit-content/-/unit/02bb76df-d066-4c08-a58a-d4686a3e68ff/41502a9f-fd21-4e0e-b2ee-3ba63a2353d5/Resources#edf2e199-794a-4ea5-b8ad-9d0fd6576ad1_en&overlay (Date of application 25.09.2023)
Bullen, R. 1988. The British Government and the Schuman Plan, May 1950 – March 1951. In: Schwabe, Klaus (Hrsg). Die Anfдnge des Schuman – Plans, 1950–1951. The Beginnings of the Schuman Plan. Baden-Baden, NOMOS, pp. 199–210.
Bullock, A. 1983. Ernest Bevin: Foreign Secretary, 1945–1951. London, William Heinemann Ltd, 896 pp.
Conclusions of a Meeting of the Cabinet, 2 June 1950. https://www.cvce.eu/en/obj/conclusions_of_a_meeting_of_the_cabinet_on_the_refusal_to_participate_in_the_negotiations_on_the_schuman_plan_london_2_june_1950-en-8737a230-6924-4905-8004-dee4385ad38e.html (Date of application 23.09.2023)
DBPO. Documents on British Policy Overseas. 1986. Series II. Volume I: The Schuman Plan, the Council of Europe and Western European Integration, May 1950 – December 1952. Ed. by Bullen, Roger and Pelly, M. E. London, Her Majesty's Stationery Office.
Dell, Ed. 1995. The Schuman Plan and the British Abdication of Leadership in Europe. New York & Oxford University Press, 336 pp.
Douglas, R. M. 2004. The Labour Party, Nationalism, and Internationalism, 1939–1951. London, Routledge, 320 pp.
Hansard House of Commons Debates, 11 May 1950, Vol. 475, р. 587.
https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/1950-05-11/debates/67f015bb-a27e-4f68-935d-1dd917a9640a/CoalAndSteelProduction(IntegrationProposals)?highlight=schuman#contribution-75cbbc8f-68d7-4447-bb9e-dfa792094ac9 (Date of application 23.09.2023)
James, R. R. 1974. Winston S. Churchill, His complete speeches: 1897–1963. Volume VIII: 1950–1963. London and New York, Chelsea House Publishers and R. R. Bowker Company.
Kennan, G. F. 1983. Memoirs, 1925–1950. Washington, Pantheon Publ., 596 pp.
Kьsters, H. J. 1988. Die Verhandlungen ьber das institutionelle System zur Grьndung der Europдische Gemeinschaft fьr Kohle und Stahl. In: Schwabe, Klaus (Hrsg) Die Anfдnge des Schuman – Plans, 1950–195. The Beginnings of the Schuman Plan. Baden-Baden, NOMOS, pp. 73–102.
Labour Party. 1950. European Union. Brousher. London.
Lord, Chr. 1996. Absent at the Creation: Britain and the Formation of the European Community, 1950–1952. Dartmouth, 175 pp.
Lord, Chr. 1998. ’With but not of Europe’: Britain and the Schuman Plan. Journal of European Integration History. Vol. IV, issue 2, pp. 23–46.
Lynch, F. 1988. The Role of Jean Monnet in Setting up the European Coal and Steel Community. In: Schwabe, Klaus (Hrsg). Die Anfдnge des Schuman – Plans, 1950–1951. The Beginnings of the Schuman Plan. Baden-Baden, NOMOS, pp. 117–130.
Milward, Al. S. 1984. The Reconstruction of Western Europe, 1945–1951. London, Methuen, 527 pp.
Morgan, K. O. 1984. Labour in Power, 1945–1951. Oxford, Oxford University Press, 564 pp.
Parker, R. A. 1986. British Perceptions of Power. Europe between the Superpowers. In: Becker, Josef and Franz Knipping (eds). Power in Europe? Great Britain, France, Italy, and West Germany in a Postwar World, 1945–1950. Berlin, Walter de Gruyter, pp. 447–460.
Shuman, R. 2001. Za Evropa [Pour Europe]. Sofia, Paper Tiger Publ., 152 s. (In Bulgarian).
Stirk, P. M. 1996. A History of European Integration Since 1914. New York, Pinter, 308 p.
Stoyanov, B. 2022. Evropa predi Evropa. Proektite za Treta sila, Evropejska federatsia i Saedineni evropejski shtati, 1945–1949 [Europe Before Europe: The Projects for the Third Power, the European Federation and the United States of Europe, 1945–1949]. Sofia, Sofia University Press, 326 s. (In Bulgarian).
Wurm, Cl. 1999. The Making of the European Community. Britain, Western Europe and European Integration, 1945–1957: The View from the Continent. European Review of History / Revue europйenne d'histoire. Vol. VI, issue 2, pp. 235–249.
Young, J. 1984. Britain, France, and the Unity of Europe, 1945–1951. London, Salem House Publ., 228 pp.