Change Management for Improving the Quality of Public Services

Keywords: resistance to change, public policy, public services, change theories, change management, quality of public services.

Abstract

The article describes peculiarities of introduction of changes in organizational structures to improve the quality of public services and resistance to these changes as an inevitable process. It is proved that the professional activity of a manager in the public sector depends on change management, and resistance to them is the main element of the change management system. The essence and interconnection of the concepts of “change management” and “resistance to change” are substantiated. The author considers the main theories of change that are used in practice in the public sector: energy, mathematical, economic, biological, systemic, psychological, psychoanalytic, political, sociological, cultural and developmental. It is proved that most theories of change emphasize that resistance to these changes is inevitable. The main reasons, forms and types of resistance in the implementation of changes and innovations by the head of a public organization are formulated.
People’s ability to adapt and deal with external variability are two key variables in determining how they will respond to change. It is taken into account that external variability is usually high for most organizations providing public services. But at the same time, public authorities, especially during the war in Ukraine, are mainly staffed by people who prefer a stable environment and well-structured ways of activity. This means that managers can expect significant resistance when trying to implement changes in public services, despite the goals of these changes.
The author formulated possible fluctuations in the attitude to changes in personnel from the announcement of them to their implementation. It is confirmed that the main reasons for resistance to changes in the provision of public services aimed at improving these services include: adherence to bureaucratic habits related to delegation of authority; skepticism; challenges associated with many hierarchical levels of authority, accountability and reporting; the tendency to push decision-making upwards, which is contrary to approaches aimed at increasing self-control and independence; relationships that are governed by the interests of many stakeholders; the presence of conflicting interests and values, and others. It is noted that the main forms of resistance to change include: apathy, tardiness, sabotage, going to the hospital, absenteism, procrastination, working by the rules, slow work, leaks in the media, backstage criticism and others. The categories of employees in the sphere of public provision, which are most vulnerable to any changes, are defined.
The author of the article developed recommendations for overcoming resistance to changes and their effective implementation to improve the quality of public services.

Downloads

Download data is not yet available.

Author Biography

Yevgen Krasnykov, Deputy Chief of the 155th Military Representation of the Ministry of Defense of Ukraine

candidate of Science in Public Administration,
Deputy Chief of the 155th Military Representation of the Ministry of Defense of Ukraine, Kharkiv, Ukraine

References

Amosov, O.Y., & Didenko, N.V. (2013). Overcoming resistance to change: theoretical approaches and implementation. Business Inform, 1, 293–298 [in Ukrainian].

Kovalenko, M. M., & Dunayev, I. V. (2023). Components of Public Policy in the Conditions of Implementation of the Mobilization Model of Economic Development. Theory and Practice of Public Administration, 1 (76), 7–25. http://doi.org/10.26565/1727-6667-2023-1-01 [in Ukrainian].

Kosach, I.A., Ladonko, L.S., & Kalinko, I.V. (2016). Business administration: organization management and change management: study guide. Kyiv, Condor, 217 [in Ukrainian].

Novikova, M. M., Borovyk, M. V., & Bubiryov, E. A. (2022). Theoretical aspects of organizational change management at the enterprise. Business Inform, 10, 219–225. https://doi.org/10.32983/2222-4459-2022-10-219-225 [in Ukrainian].

Petrova, I. L. (2008). Change management: [manual for trainers] ; [I. L. Petrova, V. I. Poli-

shchuk, V. P. Pechenizkyi, etc.]. Kyiv, Lviv,ZUKTS, 58 [in Ukrainian].

Pichugina, T. S., Tkachova, S. S., & Tkachenko, O. P. (2017). Change management: training. manual Kharkiv, KhDUHT, 226 [in Ukrainian].

Semenets-Orlova, I.A. (2016). Current strategies for overcoming resistance to educational changes. Effectiveness of state administration, 3, 60–75 [in Ukrainian].

Turchyna, S.G. (2016). Management of changes in the context of strategic development of enterprises. Bulletin of the Sumy National Agrarian University. Serie “Economics and Management”, 1 (67), 11-15 [in Ukrainian].

Ukrainian Civil Service HRM Project. Seminar “Management of changes in public administration” at the European Institute of Public Administration (EIPA). URL: http://www.ucshrm.org.ua/en/news/novini/seminar-upravlinnya-zminami-u-derzhavnomu-upravlinni-uyevropeiyskomu-instituti-derzhavnogo-upravlinnya-eipa.html [in Ukrainian].

Buchanan, D. & Boddy, D. (1993) The Expertise of the Change Agent. Public Performance and Backstage Activity. Prentice Hall [in English].

Coch, L. & French, J. R. P. (1948) ‘Overcoming Resistance to Change’. Human Relations, vol. 1, pp. 512–32 [in English].

Dawkins, R. (1997) The Selfish Gene. Macmillan [in English].

Hussey, D. E. (1995) Organisational Change. Kogan Page, 25 [in English].

Jung, C. (1953) The Integration of Personality. Farrah & Ruckhart [in English].

Lewin, K. (1951) Force Field Analysis. Harper & Row [in English].

McConkey, D. D. (1993) ‘Organisation Development in the Public Sector’ in Cummings, T. and Worley, C. G. (eds) Organisation Development and Change. 5th edn. West Publishing Co., 634–42 [in English].

Russell-Jones, N. (1995) Management Pocket Book. Alresford Press [in English].

Starkey, K. (1996) How Organisations Learn. ITP Business Press, 2 [in English].

Toffler, A. (1973) Future Shock. Pan Books [in English].

Tomkins, C. R. (1987) Achieving Economy, Efficiency and Effectiveness in the Public Sector. Kegan Paul [in English].

Weber, M. (1964) The Theory of Social and Economic Organisation. Macmillan [in English].

Zifcack, S. (1994) New Managerialism. Administrative Reform in Whitehall and Canberra. Oxford University Press, 172 [in English].

Published
2023-11-27
How to Cite
Krasnykov, Y. (2023). Change Management for Improving the Quality of Public Services. Theory and Practice of Public Administration, 2(77), 22-37. https://doi.org/10.26565/1727-6667-2023-2-02
Section
The Development of Public Administration System in Ukraine