The Policy of Decommunization in Kharkiv: the Fight for Identity

doi:10.7546/DS.2021.14.21

Halyna Kuts H. S. Skovoroda Kharkiv National Pedagogical University http://orcid.org/0000-0002-7263-1958

DOI: https://doi.org/10.7546/DS.2021.14.21

Keywords: decommunization, identity, Kharkiv, Zhukov, political stereotype, neo-Soviet identity, hybrid war

Abstract

Today Kharkiv is the border region with Russia and the frontline region, which is one of the highest numbers of internally displaced persons due to the hybrid war in the Donbas. The dominant idea of modern hybrid wars is the information wars, which are fought not for territories, but for the recoding and destruction of identity. The process of decommunization, which actively started in Ukraine after the adoption of the package of decommunization laws in 2015, has become the battlefield for identity in Kharkiv.

A key feature of Kharkiv's decommunization policy was its hybridity, which was monitored almost at every stage of the decommunization process. Hybridity was manifested in counteracting the process of decommunization, its sabotaging, delaying, imitation, demonstration of power and disregard for the opinion of different communities of the inhabitants of Kharkiv regarding toponymic policies, etc. In general, the effective public position of carriers of Ukrainian identity contributed to the effectiveness of decommunization in Kharkiv.

The three stages in the implementation of the decommunization policy in Kharkiv are distinguished and the signs of hybridity of the decommunization policy are demonstrated in each of them: the decommunization period, the post-decommunization period, the re-communisation period. Decommunization displaced most of the place names from the Kharkiv map, which were markers of Soviet identity. It was well-reasoned that the processes of reformatting the former type of disappearing Soviet identity into the neo-Soviet type of collective identity were intensified in the post-decommunization period in Kharkiv. Among the basic markers of the neo-Soviet type of collective identity, there are three groups of stereotypes that are actively embodied in the mass consciousness in post-decommunization Kharkiv: Soviet; pro-Russian; Orthodox-Moscow.

Aggressive methods of stereotyping have led to the recoding and updating of stereotypes related to the Soviet past. Zhukov's ideologue became a key marker of the hybridity of decommissioning policy in Kharkiv. Zhukov is a Soviet marshal of the Stalin era, who plays a main role in positioning his own identity for non-Soviet types of collective identity.

Downloads

Download data is not yet available.

References

BBC. 2019, 2 june. U Kharkovi povalyly byust Zhukova, Kernes obitsyaye vidnovyty [A bust of Zhukov was torn down in Kharkiv, and Kernes promises to restore it]. URL: https://www.bbc.com/ukrainian/news-48490213. (Date of the application 15.01.2021). (In Ukrainian).
Depo.Kharkiv. 2017a, 4 february. De arkhitektory Kernesa shukaly natkhnennya dlya zabudovy naybilshoyi ploshchi Yevropy [Where the architects of Kernes were looking for inspiration to build the largest square in Europe]. URL: https://kh.depo.ua/ukr/kh/de-arhitektori-kernesa-shukali-nathnennya-dlya-zabudovi-naybilshoyi-ploschi-yevropi-20170204513194. (Date of the application 15.01.2021). (In Ukrainian).
Depo.Kharkiv. 2017b, 14 february. Petytsiya za zvilnennya tvortsya «Odorobla» v Kharkovi: Zibrano polovynu pidpysiv [Petition for the dismissal of the creator of «Odorobla» in Kharkiv: Half of the signatures were collected]. URL: https://kh.depo.ua/ukr/kh/peticiya-za-zvilnennya-tvorcya-odorobla-v-harkovi-zibrano-polovinu-pidpisiv-20170214519076. (Date of the application 15.01.2021). (In Ukrainian).
Depo.Kharkiv. 2019a, 14 may. Kharkivski petytsiyi Kernesa, abo Kurs na «hromadyansku viynu» [Kernes's Kharkiv Petitions, or the Course for the Civil War]. URL: https://kh.depo.ua/ukr/kh/kharkivski-petitsii-kernesa-abo-kurs-na-gromadyansku-viynu-20190514961995. (Date of the application 15.01.2021). (In Ukrainian).
Depo.Kharkiv. 2019b, 3 june. «Zhodnoyi pravovoyi koliziyi»: U Vyatrovycha vidpovily Mendel shchodo pamyatnyka Zhukovu [«No legal conflict»: Vyatrovych was told by Mendel about the monument to Zhukov]. URL: https://www.depo.ua/ukr/politics/zhodnoi-pravovoi-kolizii-u-vyatrovicha-vidpovili-mendel-shchodo-pamyatnika-zhukovu-20190603973276. (Date of the application 15.01.2021). (In Ukrainian).
Depo.Kharkiv. 2019c, 3 june. Zelenskyy zaklykav Kernesa domovlyatysya iz kharkivyanamy pro Zhukova [Zelensky called on Kernes to reach an agreement with Kharkiv residents about Zhukov]. URL: https://kh.depo.ua/ukr/kh/zelenskiy-zaklikav-kernesa-domovlyatisya-iz-kharkivyanami-pro-zhukova-20190603973198. (Date of the application 15.01.2021). (In Ukrainian).
Dzerkalo tyzhnya. 2019, 23 december. Novyj dyrektor UINP takozh ne zgoden na prospekt imeni Zhukova v Kharkovi [The new director of the UINP also disagrees with Zhukov Avenue in Kharkiv]. URL: https://www.dt.ua/UKRAINE/noviy-direktor-uinp-takozh-ne-zgoden-na-prospekt-imeni-zhukova-v-harkovi-333794_.html. (Date of the application 15.01.2021). (In Ukrainian).
Euro.Kharkiv. 2015. Dekomunizatsiya [Decommunization]. Archives. URL: http://euro.kharkiv.ua/?tag=%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BA%D0%BE%D0%BC%D1%83%D0%BD%D1%96%D0%B7%D0%B0%D1%86%D1%96%D1%8F. (Date of the application 15.01.2021). (In Ukrainian).
Foucher M. 1999. Yevropeyskaya respublika. Istoricheskiye i geograficheskiye kontury [European Republic. Historical and geographical contours]. Moskva, Mezhdunarodnyye otnosheniya. 166 s. (In Russian).
Фуше, М. 1999. Европейская республика. Исторические и географические контуры. Москва, Международные отношения. 166 с.
Gray J. 2003. Pominki po Prosveshcheniyu. Politika i kultura na zakate sovremennosti [Enlightenment's Wake: Politics and Culture at the Close of the Modern Age]. Moskva, Praksis, 436 s. (In Russian).
Guibernau, M. 2012. Identychnist nacij [The Identity of Nations]. Kyiv, Tempora, 304 s. (In Ukrainian).
Horbulin, V. P. (et al.) 2017. Svitova gibrydna vijna: ukrayins`kyj front [World Hybrid War: Ukrainian Front]. Kyiv, NISD, 496 s. (In Ukrainian).
Kharkivska miska rada. 2015. Miskrada ukhvalyla rishennya pro pereymenuvannya vulyts, parkiv ta stantsiyi metro [The City Council has decided to rename streets, parks and metro stations]. URL: https://www.city.kharkov.ua/uk/news/miskrada-ukhvalila-rishennya-pro-pereymenuvannya-vulits-parkiv-ta-stantsii-metro-30014.html. (Date of the application 15.01.2021). (In Ukrainian).
Kharkivska miska rada. 2016. U Kharkovi pereymenuvaly shche 48 vulyts i pyat administratyvnykh rayoniv [Another 48 streets and five administrative districts were renamed in Kharkiv]. URL: https://www.city.kharkov.ua/uk/news/-30741.html. (Date of the application 15.01.2021). (In Ukrainian).
Kharkivska miska rada. 2019. U miskradi rozhlyanuly petytsiyu pro povernennya prospektu imeni Marshala Zhukova [The City Council considered a petition to return Marshal Zhukov Avenue]. URL: https://www.city.kharkov.ua/uk/news/u-miskradi-rozglyanuli-petitsiyu-pro-povernennya-prospektu-imeni-marshala-zhukova-41659.html. (Date of the application 15.01.2021). (In Ukrainian).
KharkivTimes. 2019a, 9 may. Yevromaydanivtsi: namet – vazhlyvyy obyekt v umovakh informatsiynoyi viyny! [Euromaidan residents: a tent is an important object in the conditions of information war!] URL: https://times.kharkiv.ua/uk/2019/05/09/yevromajdanivtsi-namet-vazhlivij-ob-yekt-v-umovah-informatsijnoyi-vijni/. (Date of the application 15.01.2021). (In Ukrainian).
KharkivTimes. 2019b, 12 june. U Kharkovi starovynnyy sobor 17 stolittya perefarbuvaly u kolyory moskovskoho patriarkhatu [In Kharkiv, the ancient cathedral of the 17th century was repainted in the colors of the Moscow Patriarchate]. URL: https://times.kharkiv.ua/uk/2019/06/12/u-harkovi-starovinnij-sobor-17-stolittya-perefarbuvali-u-kolori-moskovskogo-patriarhatu/. (Date of the application 15.01.2021). (In Ukrainian).
Korzeniewska-Berczyńska, J. 1996. «Homo sovieticus» v zerkale polskogo i rossiyskogo obshchestvennogo soznaniya : ctereotipy : miry : realnost [«Homo sovieticus» in the mirror of Polish and Russian public consciousness: stereotypes: worlds: reality]. Acta Polono-Ruthenica. №1, s. 359–367. (In Russian).
Kuts, H. M. 2007. Problematyka identychnosti v liberalnomu konteksti [Problems of identity in a liberal context]. Visnyk Kharkivskoho natsionalnoho universytetu imeni V. N. Karazina. Seriya: «Pytannya politolohiyi». Kharkiv, № 785, vyp. 10, s. 79–85. (In Ukrainian).
Kuts, H. M. 2014. Perypetiyi formuvannya politychnoho rezhymu v postradyanskiy Ukrayini: dosvid Maydaniv [The vicissitudes of the formation of the political regime in post-Soviet Ukraine: the experience of the Maidans]. Suchasne suspilstvo: politychni nauky: zbirnyk nauk. prats. Kharkiv, vyp. 1 (5), s. 82–94. (In Ukrainian).
Kuts, H. M. 2019. Ukrayinska ta yevropeyska identychnosti: spilne i vidminne [Ukrainian and European identity: common and different]. Polityko-pravova mentalnist ukrayinskoho sotsiumu v umovakh yevropeyskoyi intehratsiyi [Political and legal mentality of Ukrainian society in terms of European integration]. Kharkiv, Pravo. s. 414–430. (In Ukrainian).
Media Port. 2019a, 8 may. Kernes vystupaye za znesennya nametu na ploshchi Svobody ta povernennya prospektu imeni Zhukova [Kernes calls for the demolition of the tent on Freedom Square and the return of Zhukov Avenue]. URL: https://www.mediaport.ua/kernes-vistupaie-za-znesennya-nametu-na-ploshchi-svobodi-ta-povernennya-prospektu-imeni-zhukova. (Date of the application 15.01.2021). (In Ukrainian).
MediaPort. 2019b, 17 may. Takhtaulova M. Hryhorenko vs Zhukov: bataliyi na mapi Kharkova [Takhtaulova M. Grigorenko vs Zhukov: battles on the map of Kharkiv]. URL: https://www.mediaport.ua/grigorenko-vs-zhukov-bataliyi-na-mapi-harkova. (Date of the application 15.01.2021). (In Ukrainian).
Radio Svoboda. 2015, 12 november. U Xarkovi pid chas gromadskykh slukhan shchodo dekomunizaciyi stalasya bijka [A fight broke out in Kharkiv during a public hearing on decommunization]. URL: https://www.radiosvoboda.org/a/news/27361920.html. (Date of the application 15.01.2021). (In Ukrainian).
Radio Svoboda. 2016, 4 march. Kernes separatystskym mitynhom i shturmom pokazuvav Kyyevu, khto v Kharkovi lider – Baluta [Kernes with a separatist meeting and assault showed to Kiev who in Kharkiv the leader – Baluta] URL: https://www.radiosvoboda.org/a/27589884.html. (Date of the application 15.01.2021). (In Ukrainian).
Radio Svoboda. 2019, 10 may. Vyatrovych: mozhlyve pereymenuvannya prospektu v Kharkovi na chestʹ Zhukova – porushennya zakonu [Vyatrovych: it is possible to rename the avenue in Kharkiv in honor of Zhukov – a violation of the law]. URL: https://www.radiosvoboda.org/a/news-vyatrovych-prospekt-hryhorenka-harkiv/29933152.html. (Date of the application 15.01.2021). (In Ukrainian).
Rossiya 24. 2019, 14 may. Natsionalisty protiv russkogo mira: v Kharkove snosyat palatku ATO. 60 minut ot 13.05.2019. [Nationalists against the Russian world: the ATO tent is being demolished in Kharkov. 60 minutes from 13.05.2019]. URL: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Ng3SeQhuaKk. (Date of the application 15.01.2021). (In Russian).
Rozporyadzhennya KHODA. 2016. Rozporyadzhennya Kharkivskoyi oblasnoyi derzhavnoyi administratsiyi «Pro pereymenuvannya obyektiv toponimiky m. Kharkova» vid 17.05.2016 № 181. [Order of the Kharkiv Regional State Administration «On renaming of toponymy objects of Kharkiv» dated 17.05.2016 № 181]. URL: http://kharkivoda.gov.ua/content/documents/808/80788/files/160517-01-11-zagal-181-rozp.pdf. (Date of the application 15.01.2021). (In Ukrainian).
Rushchenko, I. 2015. Rosiysko-ukrayinska hibrydna viyna: pohlyad sotsioloha [Russian-Ukrainian hybrid war: the view of a sociologist]. Kharkiv, FOP Pavlenko O. H., 268 s. (In Ukrainian).
Thompson, E. М. 2006. Trubadury imperiyi: rosiysʹka literatura i kolonializm. [Imperial Knowledge: Russian Literature and Colonialism]. Kyiv, Vydavnytstvo Solomiyi Pavlychko «Osnovy», 368 s. (In Ukrainian).
Ukaz Prezydenta Ukrayiny. 2017. Ukaz Prezydenta Ukrayiny «Doktryna informatsiynoyi bezpeky Ukrayiny» vid 25.02.2017 № 47/2017 [Decree of the President of Ukraine «Doctrine of Information Security of Ukraine» dated 25.02.2017 № 47/2017]. URL: https://zakon.rada.gov.ua/laws/show/47/2017. (Date of the application 15.01.2021). (In Ukrainian).
Ukrinform. 2019, 19 june. Povernennya prospektu Zhukova u Kharkovi ye porushennyam zakonu – Vyatrovych [The return of Zhukov Avenue in Kharkiv is a violation of the law – Vyatrovych]. URL: https://www.ukrinform.ua/rubric-regions/2723888-perejmenuvanna-prospektu-grigorenka-na-prospekt-zukova-e-porusennam-zakonu-vatrovic.html. (Date of the application 15.01.2021). (In Ukrainian).
Zakon Ukrayiny. 2015. Zakon Ukrayiny «Pro zasudzhennya komunistychnogo ta nacional-socialistychnogo (nacystskogo) totalitarnykh rezhymiv v Ukrayini ta zaboronu propagandy yikhnoyi symvoliky» vid 09.04.2015 № 317-VIII [Law of Ukraine «On Condemnation of Communist and National Socialist (Nazi) Totalitarian Regimes in Ukraine and Prohibition of Propaganda of Their Symbols» dated 09.04.2015 № 317-VIII]. URL: https://zakon.rada.gov.ua/laws/show/317-19. (Date of the application 15.01.2021). (In Ukrainian).