Pragmatism of interstate relations between Ukraine and Poland at the present stage
Abstract
The strategic partnership between Ukraine and Poland over the past decades has withstood periods of interstate tension and prosperity and has a positive prospect of further cooperation. The aim of the study is to find out the causes of misunderstandings and contradictions between Ukraine and Poland based on the analysis of Ukrainian-Polish relations during the twentieth century, to reveal the preconditions and ways to cooperation between the two countries in Europe and the world. The article shows that most of the Polish-Ukrainian conflicts were based on territorial claims to the Right Bank and Eastern Galicia, which were put forward by part of the Polish nationalist political forces on the basis of "historical law" in the late nineteenth century. Their non-recognition of the right of Ukrainians to their own statehood led to the radicalization of the Ukrainian national liberation movement in the interwar period and the armed confrontation during the Second World War. The formation of a new doctrine of Ukrainian-Polish relations took place in the circles of Polish emigrants, in particular those who grouped around the Prague edition of the magazine "Culture" led by E. Giedroyc in the postwar period. It provided for the creation of independent and democratic states - Poland and Ukraine and the formation of friendly relations between them. This doctrine was the basis of relations between Poland and Ukraine in the early 90's of the twentieth century and contributed to their transformation into strategic partners in Europe and the world.
It has been shown that over the past 30 years, Polish-Ukrainian interstate relations have been built on mutual interest in the military, economic, cultural, educational, and security spheres. Poland, integrated into the European space, contributed to the establishment of Ukraine's cooperation with European structures. In order to preserve and develop mutually beneficial pragmatic relations between Poland and Ukraine, it is necessary that the issues of the historical past of the two peoples do not become the subject of state policy. It is most appropriate to continue the earlier discussion of historians on the complex issues of the past to understand and accept the historical truth by both parties.
Downloads
References
Kozytskyi A. 2013. Volyn: nevdala sproba «ostatochnoho rozviazannia» naukovoi problemy [Volyn: an unsuccessful attempt to "finally solve" a scientific problem]. URL: https://www.istpravda.com.ua/articles/2013/06/6/12554. (Date of the application: 18.12.2020 ). (In Ukrainian).
Komorovskyi, B. 2015. Za nashu i vashu svobodu! Khai zhyve vilna, demokratychna i yevropeiska Ukraina [For our and your freedom! Long live a free, democratic and European Ukraine]. URL: https://www.eurointegration.com.ua/articles/2015/04/9. (Date of the application: 18.12.2020 ). (In Ukrainian).
Lysiak-Rudnytskyi, I. 1994. Polsko-ukrainski stosunky: tiahar istorii [Polish-Ukrainian relations: the burden of history]. Istorychni ese. Kyiv. T. 1. S. 83-111
Mieliekiestsev, K. I. 2019. Ukraina ta Respublika Polshcha: vid bilateralnykh vidnosyn do yevroatlantychnoi intehratsii (istorychnyi aspekt) [Ukraine and the Republic of Poland: from bilateral relations to Euro-Atlantic integration (historical aspect)]. URL: https://chtyvo.org.ua/authors/Mieliekiestsev_Kyrylo/Ukraina_ta_Respublika_Polsc. (Date of the application: 18.12.2020 ). (In Ukrainian).
Panchenko, Yu. 2020. Aleksandr Kvasnevskyi: Andzhei Duda maie shans na proryv u prymyrenni z Ukrainoiu [Alexander Kwasniewski: Andrzej Duda has a chance for a breakthrough in reconciliation with Ukraine]. URL: https://www.eurointegration.com.ua/interview/2020/10/8/7115122. (Date of the application: 19.11.2020). (In Ukrainian).
Pyrih, V. 2020. Ukraina, Polshcha i Lytva stvoryly novyi format mizhderzhavnoi vzaiemodii [Ukraine, Poland and Lithuania have created a new format of interstate cooperation]. URL: https://zaxid.net/news/. (Date of the application: 19.11.2020). (In Ukrainian).
Stoietskyi, S. 2005. Kontseptsiia stratehichnoho partnerstva v politytsi Respubliky Polshcha shchodo Ukrainy [The concept of strategic partnership in the policy of the Republic of Poland towards Ukraine]. Politychnyi menedzhment. № 3. S. 147-158. (In Ukrainian).
Shchodo ukrainsko-polskykh vidnosyn [Regarding Ukrainian-Polish relations]. 2019. Analitychna zapyska. Seriia «Hromadianske suspilstvo». № 2. 8 s. https://niss.gov.ua/sites/default/files/2019-09/analit-smenkovsky-yavoska-kaplan-civil. (Date of the application: 19.11.2020). (In Ukrainian).
Yakovlieva, I. V. 2013. Heneza formuvannia kontseptualnykh zasad skhidnoho napriamku zovnishnoi polityky Respubliky Polshcha [The genesis of the formation of the conceptual foundations of the eastern direction of the foreign policy of the Republic of Poland]. Aktualni problemy polityky. Vyp. 48. S. 284-289. (In Ukrainian).
Voroshylov, O. 2020. Vizyt Prezydenta Polshchi A. Dudy v Ukrainu 11–13 zhovtnia 2020 r. [Visit of the President of Poland A. Duda to Ukraine on October 11-13, 2020]. Ukraina: podii, fakty, komentari. 2020. № 13. S. 4–12. (In Ukrainian).
Zhelikhovskyi, S., 2020. Panchenko Yu. Boikot dlia Dudy: yak zminytsia Polshcha pislia vyboriv i shcho tse oznachaie dlia Ukrainy [Boycott for Duda: how Poland will change after the election and what it means for Ukraine]. URL: https://www.eurointegration.com.ua/articles/2020/08/7/7112941. (Date of the application: 19.11.2020). (In Ukrainian).
Zashkilniak, L. 2008. Ukraina i Polshcha v XX stolitti: vid konfliktiv do porozuminnia [Ukraine and Poland in the twentieth century: from conflicts to understanding]. Ukraina: kulturna spadshchyna, natsionalna svidomist, derzhavnist. Vyp. 17. S. 3-18. (In Ukrainian).
Zashkilniak, L. 2018. Polskyi vektor u politytsi ukrainskoho natsionalno-vyzvolnoho rukhu v roky Druhoi svitovoi viiny [The Polish vector in the policy of the Ukrainian national liberation movement during the Second World War]. Naukovi zapysky Natsionalnoho universytetu «Ostrozka akademiia». Seriia «Istorychni nauky». № 27. S. 104-112. (In Ukrainian).
Zashkilniak, L. Ohliad problem spilnoi (vazhkoi) istorii ukraintsiv i poliakiv KhKh stolittia [Review of the problems of the common (difficult) history of Ukrainians and Poles of the twentieth century]. URL: https://old.uinp.gov.ua/news/oglyad-problem-spilnoi-vazhkoi-istorii-ukraintsiv-i-polyakiv-khkh-stolittya. (Date of the application: 19.11.2020). (In Ukrainian).
Znakhorenko, O. M. 2008. Stratehichne partnerstvo v ukrainsko-polskykh vidnosynakh [Strategic partnership in Ukrainian-Polish relations]. Istorychnyi arkhiv. Vyp. 2. S. 90-98. (In Ukrainian).