Correlation of public and private interest in sectoral policies (using the example of the meat sector of the food complex of Ukraine)
Abstract
The article addresses the complex interplay between public and private interests in sectoral policy, with a specific focus on the meat sector of Ukraine’s agri-food complex. Against the backdrop of increasing involvement of non-state actors in governance processes and the ongoing transformation of public administration, the study explores the risks and consequences of blurred boundaries between state responsibilities and private initiatives. It emphasizes that when public and private domains are not clearly delineated, it may lead to inefficiencies in policy implementation, a lack of accountability, regulatory capture, and threats to public health and environmental sustainability. The authors systematically classify and contrast public and private interests across all stages of the meat value chain: production, processing, storage, distribution, sale, and consumption. Public interests are identified as food safety, environmental protection, animal welfare, public health, and the promotion of fair competition and national food security. Conversely, private interests are focused on profit maximization, cost reduction, market expansion, and risk minimization. Through an interdisciplinary analysis incorporating governance theory, legal interpretations, and regulatory impact assessment methodology, the article demonstrates that the meat sector meets all criteria to be recognized as an object of public governance. It argues that sectoral regulation must go beyond market coordination and should involve institutional mechanisms that ensure a balance between commercial goals and collective societal needs. The authors highlight the importance of regulatory tools such as public-private partnerships, transparent subsidy mechanisms, safety standards enforcement, and the prevention of monopolization and corruption. Moreover, the article identifies a pressing need to refine Ukraine’s regulatory framework by clearly defining the scope of state intervention and accountability, especially in strategically sensitive areas like food production. The study suggests that without transparent rules and an effective division of roles between public authorities, business, and civil society, there is a high risk of private interests dominating public policy, leading to social and ecological harm. The article contributes to the academic discussion on collaborative governance and the institutionalization of public interest in sectoral policy. It provides a valuable basis for future research focused on designing effective models of public-private interaction, adapting international best practices in food safety regulation, and evaluating the institutional capacity of public bodies responsible for managing the meat industry under conditions of war and economic instability.
Downloads
References
Berestova, I.E. (2019) The legal category of “public interest” from the standpoint of a systemic approach. The rule of law, 33, 19–28. [in Ukrainian]
Bernazyuk, Ya.O. (2021) Signs and content of public (public) interest, its correlation with state interests. Law and Society, 6, 146–153. [in Ukrainian]
Venediktova, I.V. (2011) Methodological principles of legally protected interests in private law: monograph. Khakiv: Novye Slovo. 260 p. [in Ukrainian]
Venediktova, I.V. (2013) Public interests in civil law. Bulletin of the Kharkiv National University named after V. N. Karazin. Series: Law. 1082, Issue 16, 97–100. [in Ukrainian]
Vinnyk, O.M. (2003) Public and private interests in business partnerships: problems of legal support: monograph. Kyiv: Atika. 352 p. [in Ukrainian]
Galunko, V.V. (2010) Public interest in administrative law. Law Forum, 4, 178–182. [in Ukrainian]
Dzhumageldieva, G.D. (2018) Criteria of private and public interests in regulatory activity. Legal journal of Donetsk University, 1-2, 17–23. [in Ukrainian]
Dzyundzyuk, V.B. (2002) Peculiarities of management of private and public organizations. Bulletin of the Kharkiv National University of Internal Affairs, 20, 183–188. [in Ukrainian]
Karnaukhova, M.D. (2019) Demarcation of public and private in the discursive space of governance. Aspects of public administration, 7, 3, 38–49. [in Ukrainian]
Klymenko, O.V. (2015) Administrative and legal support of the balance of public and private interests in state regulation of economic activity. Customs, 3(2), 140–146. [in Ukrainian]
Lukach, I. (2016) Paradigm of public and private norms in the regulation of economic relations. Entrepreneurship, economy and law, 8, 43–46. [in Ukrainian]
Melnyk, R.S., Bevzenko V.M. (2014) General administrative law: Textbook / Edited by R.S. Melnyk. Kyiv: Vaite. 376 p. [in Ukrainian]
Resolution of the Grand Chamber of the Supreme Court of February 13, 2019 in case No. 810/2763/17. URL: https://reyestr.court.gov.ua/Review/79883398 (date of access 01/20/2025)
On approval of methods for conducting impact analysis and monitoring the effectiveness of a regulatory act: Resolution of the Cabinet of Ministers of Ukraine of March 11, 2004 No. 308.
Rabinovych, P.M. (2004) Private and public in private law. Current problems of the state and law, 23, 30–34. [in Ukrainian]
Raimov, R.I. (2019) Ensuring public interest as a principle of administrative and legal regulation of the activities of natural monopolies. Bulletin of the Southern Regional Center of the National Academy of Legal Sciences of Ukraine, 19, 115–122. [in Ukrainian]
Savchenko, S.V. (2013) The relationship between private and public interests: the experience of Ukraine. Forum of Law, 3, 520–528. [in Ukrainian]
Selivanov, V. (2001) Private law principles of the development of domestic legal science. Law of Ukraine, 3, 21–32. [in Ukrainian]
Soroka, L.V. (2020) State regulation and management and their relationship with public administration. Current problems of state and law, 86, 204–209. [in Ukrainian]
Teremtsova, N.V. (2019) Criteria for dividing law into private and public. Sociology of law, 1-2, 123–129. [in Ukrainian]
Shcherbyna, V.S. (2016) Public and private interests in economic relations. Private law and entrepreneurship, 15, 25–28. [in Ukrainian]
Basaj, W.D. (2006) Mutual relations of interests on the basis of private and public law. The concept of interest w naukach prawnych prawie stanowionym i orzecznictwie sądowym Polski i Ukrainy. Lublin. P. 55–59.
Copyright (c) 2025 Pressing Problems of Public Administration

This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.