IMPROVING THE PERFORMANCE INDICATORS OF SMALL HYDROPOWER PLANTS THROUGH OPTIMIZATION OF CONTROL SYSTEMS
Abstract
DOI: https://doi.org/10.26565/2079-1747-2025-36-07
The article addresses the problem of improving the comprehensive quality indicators of small hydropower plants by optimizing the automatic control systems of hydroelectric generating units. It is shown that, under conditions of increasing penetration of decentralized energy sources and heightened requirements for energy efficiency, the quality of dynamic processes occurring during load changes in small HPPs becomes particularly important. To solve this problem, an approach is proposed for optimizing the parameters of a PID controller within the automatic speed regulation system of a hydroturbine, based on modeling its dynamics as a second-order system with typical hydraulic and electromechanical time constants. A model of a small-capacity Francis turbine with nominal parameters – net head of 74 m, discharge of 2.05 m³/s, and nominal output of approximately 1.28 MW – is used as the research object. Generalized head, efficiency, and power characteristics of the turbine are presented. Simulation studies of the turbine’s response to step load changes were carried out for two configurations of the PID controller: non-optimal and optimized. A quantitative assessment of transient quality was performed using integral error- and time-based criteria, as well as energy efficiency indicators, including the relative loss of generated energy during the transient mode. It is demonstrated that optimal PID tuning significantly reduces the amplitude and duration of oscillations, accelerates the establishment of steady-state conditions, and decreases energy losses from 12.9% to 2.1%. A comprehensive quality index is proposed, integrating dynamic and energy criteria, which can be used as a universal metric for comparing different control strategies. The obtained results confirm the feasibility of optimizing control systems as one of the most effective ways to enhance the performance and reliability of small hydropower plants.
Downloads
References
Ciontu, M, Popescu, D. & Motocu, M 2010, ‘Analysis of energy efficiency by replacing the throttle valve with variable speed drive condensate pump from E.C. Turceni’, Published in International Conference on… 11 November 2010. Engineering, Environmental Science. DOI:10.1109/ISEEE.2010.5628495 Corpus ID: 11478409
Alternate Hydro Energy Centre, 2010, Standards / manuals / guidelines for small hydro development. Part 3-1: Selection of turbine and governing system, viewed <https://www.ieahydro.org/media/4992a422/3-1-Selection-of-turbine-and-governing-system.pdf >
Small-Hydro Manual, 2005, viewed <https://openjicareport.jica.go.jp/pdf/11810165_04.pdf>
Energy Community Secretariat 2022, Guide on how to develop a small hydropower plant, viewed <https://energycommunityplatform.eu/wp-content/uploads/2022/06/Merged-Guide-Develop-a-Small-Hydropower-Plant.pdf>
Small hydropower technologies – European state-of-the-art handbook. HYPOSO Project. Stuttgart, 2021, viewed <https://www.hyposo.eu/HYPOSO_Publications/hyposo-handbook-final.pdf>
Skorohoda, VV & Solonina, YuM (ed) 2013, Mala gidroenergetika Ukrayini. Tom II. Tehnologichni aspekti rozvitku [ Small Hydropower of Ukraine. Volume II. Technological Aspects of Development ], In-t vidnovlyuvanoyi energetiki NAN Ukrayini, Kyiv.
Vasko, PF & Ibragimova, MR 2015, ‘Energetichna efektivnist gidroagregativ u skladi maloyi gidroelektrostanciyi za regulyuvannya yiyi potuzhnosti po vodotoku’ [Energy efficiency of hydraulic units in a small hydroelectric power plant for regulating its power along the watercourse. ], Vidnovlyuvana energetika, no 4, Pp. 44-49.
Klyuha, OO 2013, ‘Suchasnij stan ta problemi rozvitku maloyi gidroenergetiki Ukrayini’ [ Current status and problems of development of small hydropower in Ukraine ], Visnik NUVGP. Seriya «Energetika», iss. 2(62), Pp. 151-156.
Zin, MM 2018, ‘Rozrahunok i proektuvannya gidroagregativ z gidroturbinami maloyi potuzhnosti’ [ Calculation and design of hydraulic units with low-power hydraulic turbines ], Materiali MNTK «Problemi gidroenergetiki», Ternopil, Pp. 252–253.
Bril, AO, Vasko, PF & Moroz, AV 2019, ‘Tehnichnij potencial gidroenergetichnih resursiv malih richok Ukrayini z urahuvannyam prirodoohoronnih obmezhen’ [Technical potential of hydropower resources of small rivers of Ukraine taking into account environmental restrictions ], Gidroenergetika Ukrayini, no 3-4, Pp. 47-51.
Drankovskij, VYe & Kuhtenkov, YuM 2023, Gidravlichni elektrichni stanciyi [Hydraulic power plants ], NTU «HPI», Harkiv.
Prasad, D & Kumar, R 2012, ‘Modeling of hydraulic turbine and governor for dynamic studies of small hydropower plants’, Int. J. Computer Applications, Vol. 1, P. 1-7.
Okonkwo, GN 2023, ‘Control of a small hydropower system for power supply in a remote community’, Global Scientific Journal, Vol. 11, no. 5, P. 165-176.
Ngoma, DH 2025, ‘Comparative control governor systems for power and frequency optimization in off-grid small hydropower plants’, Energy Systems, viewed <https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s43937-025-00066-8>
Zhu, Z 2025, ‘Optimal guide vane opening-based variable-speed control for small hydropower units: enhancing efficiency under wide head fluctuations’, Energy, Vol. 290, Article 130356. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.energy.2025.139111
